"fake Floyd since The Wall"
I despise that album. It isn't Pink Floyd.
Well, obviously it IS Pink FLoyd; in fact, it's the greatest (as in most expansive) eexpression of what they wanted Floyd to BE. I don't think it's their best, but it's what Gilmour and especially Waters wanted it to be, and as someone who prefers Wish You were Here, Meddle and Dark Side... I have to say they can't just repeat themselves, they had to go into other areas, and I think this is the logical extension of the other albums.