Well, obviously it IS Pink FLoyd; in fact, it's the greatest (as in most expansive) eexpression of what they wanted Floyd to BE. I don't think it's their best, but it's what Gilmour and especially Waters wanted it to be, and as someone who prefers Wish You were Here, Meddle and Dark Side... I have to say they can't just repeat themselves, they had to go into other areas, and I think this is the logical extension of the other albums.
"I have to say they can't just repeat themselves, they had to go into other areas"
Well, perhaps. I think I've listened to it once, and that was enough.
Well, it's what Waters wanted it to be. The Wall is a Waters solo album with the limited amount that Gilmour was allowed to contribute being the only thing making the album what it is. Otherwise, it's the Final Cut or Radio K.A.O.S.