"http://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/archives/american_idol_5/2006_Apr_21_taylor_scripted
Taylor's selection of the "safe" group was scripted by American Idol's producer
On Wednesdays American Idol 5 elimination episode, Ryan Seacrest told Taylor Hicks to join the group he thought would be safe. Taylor pretended to join one group but then faked them out, joining the correct safe group instead.
As it turns out, this whole act was, naturally, just another example of executive producer Nigel Lythgoes sadism. Although Lythgoe did not know who was eliminated, he did know which contestants were in the bottom three, so he instructed Taylor to shake hands with Chris and then go to the other group. Basically, the whole thing was scripted.
Access Hollywoods Laura Saltman has the details:
Dont think Taylor picking the safe group was of his own accord. During the commercial break, Executive Producer, Nigel Lythgoe, filled Taylor in on the fake-out handshake to Chris Daughtry and which group to choose. It turns out Nigel doesnt know who is going to be eliminated. He is kept in the dark until the very end. The only thing he knows is which three contestants are in the bottom three.