American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part II)

FOX ^ | 3-25-06

[silent_jonny]

still for Tammy

[Feiny]

Paris has way more singing ability than Kelly.
I am a Kelly Hater. She gives validity to blonde jokes.

[Wolfstar]

Last year, we suspected that this was the case with Carrie. Every week she had a different look (remember Jonbenet week?) and sometimes tried to sound more "pop" instead of Country.

I do remember Jonbenet week. It was creepy. That's when I began turning from being a fan of hers to not. But you know, it didn't occur to me until Netizen pointed it out that the advice coming from so many people so fast might confuse them. It's an excellent point.

[Carolinamom]

If the rumor is true that tonight's singer getting the ax is going to be a shocker, could it be Taylor? Simon keeps referring to his performances as cabaret singing.

[BamaDi]

I hope both of ya'll are right - I want Paris GONE!

[Feiny]

America is addicted to oil & Idol.

[Wolfstar]

I think she will end up in porn.....accidentally of course.

I don't think so.

[BamaDi]

that's what Simon used to say about Clay....while the others would get PO'd when critized...Clay would always absorb it and do what ever advice was offered....I really really am liking Elliot (not better than Taylor or course)....but I think this kid will have a future....

[Feiny]

Come on...some guy will open her pickle jar & catch it all on hidden camera.....voila The Pickler Sex Tape...just like Paris Hilton....or Pam Anderson. Mark my words.....if it doesn't happen...I will do it myself.

[Carolinamom]

Kellie has come a long way...farther than I thought she would...and could very well get some role in show business either in modeling, recording, or a sit-come. Give her credit for coming this far from her beginnings whether you like her or not.

[MOgirl]

Hello,

First time on this thread, but I got totally addicted to AI this year. Kelly is a sweet girl, but I think she may go this evening. Her last two performances were weak. We'll see.

And by the way, what in heck was up with Paula last night?

Glad to be here, MOgirl

[misterrob]

Tell us how you really feel!

[Netizen]

Last year, we suspected that this was the case with Carrie. Every week she had a different look (remember Jonbenet week?) and sometimes tried to sound more "pop" instead of Country.

I think that's the stylists and I would put that into a different category as their singing abilities. Too much advice could really mess them up. But, I do think a stylist could sabatoge a person's looks. I think we have seen it. Going to have to watch for it more. :) Bucky was smart to say 'never again' after what they did to his hair. LOL

[Feiny]

No...you can't make me.
I refuse to give her credit as I think she is irresponsible & would just max out the card & never pay the bills.

[BamaDi]

and i'm the dumb sh$% that just got rid of a camry and bought a 4Runner....but hey, I can afford the gas so screw it....(does that sound brave????)

[Netizen]

PS: Look at what the stylists do to Paris each week. She should be acting like Sybil by now! LOL

[Feiny]

Paula is always wasted...it is actually part of her contract.

[Feiny]

Sure...you can be brave in a big ole SUV.
You can just drive over anyone who mocks you.

I bought a used Prius last year so I laugh at gas prices.

[silent_jonny]

Just goes to show that the old saying had it right, and this is never more so when the eye of the beholder is male vs. female. :)

;)

I agree with you when it comes to McPhee's personality--she's seems cold and distant.

But when it comes to her body, we part ways

[BamaDi]

a friend of mine watched AI last night for the first time and she loooooooved Elliot...of course I'm not too sure about her since she didn't like Taylor at all! she was impressed by Kat and laughed her a$$ off about Kelly....I had to admit to her that I've liked Kelly until last night but now it's time for her (and Paris) to gooooooo! And jonny, what's with the boobs?

[Feiny]

I wasn't always this cruel ....she just brings out the worst in me.