Yes, hours. So far we've direct-linked to two, maybe three products in this thread that fit the bill (wrapping paper, with a "click here to purchase" button). Several people have made some interesting alternative suggestions or pointed in the general direction of a website or search engine, but not many have posted hard links to actual product. And with good reason; they're hard to find (Google spits out hundreds of useless links however you phrase your search). If it were truly simple, we would have seen more links posted.
I hoped someone else had already found a good source.
I generally use a pretty, solid colored, metallic type paper with a nice ribbon, bow and appropriate tag. I gave you the Google search result link for quite a few sites dealing in Christian-themed wrapping paper, assuming you could search the Christmas offerings yourself. Sorry it didnt help.