I'll take Gilmour anyday.
Waters ...however tortured talented he is
comes across as arrogant as all hell
i've seen interviews with Gilmour....a decent soft spoken fellow....rather humble....i can see how they clashed
and Gilmour drove a beat up land rover from England to North Africa to fetch a desolate and abandoned and utterly fried Syd back in the very early days
he may not be perfect and swings left but he has a heart and backs up his talk with charity
and plays a unique understated guitar like no one.
In another interview a short while back Waters claimed that he and Gilmour are miles apart politically. So is Waters miles left of Gilmour?
Concur on Gilmour's understated guitar style. ....always tasteful and soulful.
Far away across the field
The tolling of the iron bell
Calls the faithful to their knees
To hear the softly spoken magic spells.