[Diddle E. Squat]

Either you base it on stats, or you have to get into such a convoluted statistical analysis of each game pitched, against which teams that it become idiotic. Anything else is just personal preferences and voting with your emotions.

But of course your choice of which stats to use (and which to exclude) wasn't in the least based on personal preferences or emotions. < / sarc >

As sure as the sun rising every the morning, Cardinal myopia returns each season.

[SCALEMAN]

But of course your choice of which stats to use (and which to exclude) wasn't in the least based on personal preferences or emotions. < / sarc > As sure as the sun rising every the morning, Cardinal myopia returns each season

Actually you are wrong. I could care less who gets the Cy. It won't effect how the Cards do and is a vanity award until such time as guidelines are set down by MLB.

The same applies to the MVP. It is meaningless to the game, just an opinion poll.