[grellis]

I don't think DD would have created a horcrux, not even a "Horcrux-lite." He more or less said that the splitting of a soul was (here's a word I'm getting tired of reading) an abomination.

[kellynch]

I'm not saying I agreed with her, I just said I found her theory to be fascinating. I happen to agree that Dumbledore would not do anything that could be construed as "Dark."

And, speaking of Voldemort's Horcruxes, some seem to believe that Harry's scar may be one.