Skip to comments.
AMD sues Intel over antitrust issues
Marketwatch ^
| 11:02 AM ET June 28, 2005
| Matt Andrejczak, MarketWatch
Posted on 06/28/2005 8:07:12 AM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach
SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) -- Advanced Micro Devices Inc. has sued its larger rival Intel Corp. for holding an unlawful monopoly in the market for chips that power personal computers.
AMD, in a 48-page suit filed late Monday in Delaware federal court, accused Intel of using improper subsidies and threatened retaliation against computer makers, vendors, and retailers using or selling AMD products.
Intel's chips power more than 82% of the world's personal computers. The allegations come as AMD's market share in the microprocessor market has slid from 20.2% to 15.8% since 2001.
AMD, which launched a new chip for desktops and laptops in late 2003 and has had some initial success in the corporate client PC market, seeks to step up pressure on Intel in the market for microprocessors, the brains of the computer.
The Sunnyvale, Calif.-based company plans to spin off its financially-troubled flash memory chip unit sometime this year to devote its resources to computer chips for computers and servers.
By alleging monopolist behavior, AMD aims to prove that Intel is harming consumers, forcing them to pay inflated prices for PCs.
"Everywhere in the world, customers deserve freedom of choice and the benefits of innovation -- and these are being stolen away in the microprocessor market," said Hector Ruiz, AMD chairman of the board, president and chief executive officer.
In midmorning trading, Intel
(INTC: news, chart, profile)
shares rose 32 cents to $26.18. AMD
(AMD:
news, chart, profile)
rose 39 cents to $17.05
Japanese regulators had previously found that Intel abused its monopoly power, while the European Commission is also probing Intel on antitrust concerns. Intel did not contest the Japanese ruling.
An Intel spokesman told the Wall Street Journal he hadn't seen the suit and that it believes its sales practices are fair and consistent with antitrust law.
AMD's complaint lists examples of what it characterizes as bribes, threats or intimidation by Intel involving 12 computer makers, nine distributors and 17 retailers.
Customers cited include International Business Machines Corp.
(IBM: news,
chart, profile)
, Hewlett-Packard Co.
(HPQ: news, chart, profile)
, Dell Inc.
(DELL: news, chart, profile)
, Sony Corp.
(SNE:
news, chart, profile)
, Toshiba Corp. and Gateway Inc.
(GTW: news, chart, profile)
.
In discussions about buying from AMD, "Dell executives have frankly conceded that they must financially account for Intel retribution in negotiating pricing from AMD," the suit alleges.
AMD has been trying to persuade Dell to sell its x86 microprocessor.
AMD said it's been completely shut out from Media Markt, Europe's largest computer retailer and a division of Metro AG (DE:725750: news, chart, profile) , and Office Depot
(ODP: news, chart, profile)
, which declined to stock AMD-powered notebooks.
Matt Andrejczak is a reporter for MarketWatch in San Francisco.
|
|
TOPICS: Business/Economy; Computers/Internet
KEYWORDS: amd; intel
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-22 next last
To: ShadowAce
To: All
From :
2cpu.com
AMD sues Intel, the monopolist
By duke on Tuesday, June 28, 2005 at 9:31 AM EST [ 1 Comment ] #3746
The Inquirer is reporting that AMD has filed an antitrust complaint against Intel. AMD says Intel has paid Dell and Toshiba huge sums not to do business with AMD. It says Sony was paid "millions for exclusivity" and as a result AMDs share of Sonys business went from 23 percent in 2002 to 8% in 2003, down to 0% today.
AMD has even setup a website discussing the issue. You can read more over here.
To: All
And from AMD:
***************************************************************************
|
|
AMD Files Antitrust Complaint Against Intel In U.S. Federal District Court
​ ​​​​ Complaint Details Worldwide Coercion of Computer-Makers, System-Builders, Distributors and Retailers from Dealing with AMD Intels Illegal Acts Inflate Computer Prices and Limit Choices for Businesses and Consumers
SUNNYVALE, Calif. -- June 28, 2005 --AMD (NYSE: AMD) announced today that it filed an antitrust complaint against Intel Corporation (Intel) yesterday in U.S. federal district court for the district of Delaware under Section 2 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, Sections 4 and 16 of the Clayton Act, and the California Business and Professions Code. The 48-page complaint explains in detail how Intel has unlawfully maintained its monopoly in the x86 microprocessor market by engaging in worldwide coercion of customers from dealing with AMD. It identifies 38 companies that have been victims of coercion by Intel including large scale computer-makers, small system-builders, wholesale distributors, and retailers, through seven types of illegality across three continents.
Everywhere in the world, customers deserve freedom of choice and the benefits of innovation and these are being stolen away in the microprocessor market, said Hector Ruiz, AMD chairman of the board, president and chief executive officer. Whether through higher prices from monopoly profits, fewer choices in the marketplace or barriers to innovation people from Osaka to Frankfurt to Chicago pay the price in cash every day for Intels monopoly abuses.
x86 microprocessors run the Microsoft Windows®, Solaris and Linux families of operating systems. Even Apple®, a pioneer of the PC and one of the industrys enduring innovators, announced that it would switch exclusively to x86 processors to run Mac OS® software beginning in 2006. Intels share of this critical market currently counts for about 80 percent of worldwide sales by unit volume and 90 percent by revenue, giving it entrenched monopoly ownership and super-dominant market power.
This litigation follows a recent ruling from the Fair Trade Commission of Japan (JFTC), which found that Intel abused its monopoly power to exclude fair and open competition, violating Section 3 of Japans Antimonopoly Act. These findings reveal that Intel deliberately engaged in illegal business practices to stop AMDs increasing market share by imposing limitations on Japanese PC manufacturers. Intel did not contest these charges.
The European Commission has stated that it is pursuing an investigation against Intel for similar possible antitrust violations and is cooperating with the Japanese authorities.
You dont have to take our word for it when it comes to Intels abuses; the Japanese government condemned Intel for its exclusionary and illegal misconduct, said Thomas M. McCoy, AMD executive vice president, legal affairs and chief administrative officer. We encourage regulators around the world to take a close look at the market failure and consumer harm Intels business practices are causing in their nations. Intel maintains illegal monopoly profits at the expense of consumers and computer manufacturers, whose margins are razor thin. Now is the time for consumers and the industry worldwide to break free from the abusive Intel monopoly.
The 48-page complaint, drafted after an intensive investigation by AMDs lead outside counsel, Charles P. Diamond of OMelveny & Myers LLP, details numerous examples of what Diamond describes as a pervasive, global scheme to coerce Intel customers from freely dealing with AMD to the detriment of customers and consumers worldwide. According to the complaint, Intel has unlawfully maintained its monopoly by, among other things:
- Forcing major customers such as Dell, Sony, Toshiba, Gateway, and Hitachi into Intel-exclusive deals in return for outright cash payments, discriminatory pricing or marketing subsidies conditioned on the exclusion of AMD;
- According to industry reports, and as confirmed by the JFTC in Japan, Intel has paid Dell and Toshiba huge sums not to do business with AMD.
- Intel paid Sony millions for exclusivity. AMDs share of Sonys business went from 23 percent in 02 to 8% in 03, to 0%, where it remains today.
- Forcing other major customers such as NEC, Acer, and Fujitsu into partial exclusivity agreements by conditioning rebates, allowances and market development funds (MDF) on customers agreement to severely limit or forego entirely purchases from AMD;
- Intel paid NEC several million dollars for caps on NECs purchases from AMD. Those caps assured Intel at least 90% of NECs business in Japan and imposed a worldwide cap on the amount of AMD business NEC could do.
- Establishing a system of discriminatory and retroactive incentives triggered by purchases at such high levels as to have the intended effect of denying customers the freedom to purchase any significant volume of processors from AMD;
- When AMD succeeded in getting on the HP retail roadmap for mobile computers, and its products sold well, Intel responded by withholding HPs fourth quarter 2004 rebate check and refusing to waive HPs failure to achieve its targeted rebate goal; it allowed HP to make up the shortfall in succeeding quarters by promising Intel at least 90% of HPs mainstream retail business.
- Threatening retaliation against customers for introducing AMD computer platforms, particularly in strategic market segments such as commercial desktop;
- Then-Compaq CEO Michael Capellas said in 2000 that because of the volume of business given to AMD, Intel withheld delivery of critical server chips. Saying he had a gun to his head, he told AMD he had to stop buying.
- According to Gateway executives, their company has paid a high price for even its limited AMD dealings. They claim that Intel has beaten them into guacamole in retaliation.
- Establishing and enforcing quotas among key retailers such as Best Buy and Circuit City, effectively requiring them to stock overwhelmingly or exclusively, Intel computers, artificially limiting consumer choice;
- AMD has been entirely shut out from Media Markt, Europes largest computer retailer, which accounts for 35 percent of Germanys retail sales.
- Office Depot declined to stock AMD-powered notebooks regardless of the amount of financial support AMD offered, citing the risk of retaliation.
- Forcing PC makers and tech partners to boycott AMD product launches or promotions;
- Then-Intel CEO Craig Barrett threatened Acers Chairman with severe consequences for supporting the AMD Athlon 64 launch. This coincided with an unexplained delay by Intel in providing $15-20M in market development funds owed to Acer. Acer withdrew from the launch in September 2003.
- Abusing its market power by forcing on the industry technical standards and products that have as their main purpose the handicapping of AMD in the marketplace.
- Intel denied AMD access to the highest level of membership for the Advanced DRAM technology consortium to limit AMDs participation in critical industry standard decisions that would affect its business.
- Intel designed its compilers, which translate software programs into machine-readable language, to degrade a programs performance if operated on a computer powered by an AMD microprocessor.
To view the full text of the complaint, please visit http://www.amd.com/breakfree.
Leading publications such as The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, The Economist, San Jose Mercury News and CNET have recognized AMD as a leader in microprocessor innovation. AMD has achieved technological leadership in critical aspects of the x86 market, particularly with its AMD Opteron microprocessor, the first microprocessor to take x86 computing from 32 to 64 bits, and with its dual-core processors. The company has also stated its commitment to help deliver basic computing and Internet connectivity to 50 percent of the worlds population by the year 2015.
Press and Analyst Conference Call Hector Ruiz, AMD chairman, president and CEO; Thomas M. McCoy, AMD executive vice president, legal affairs and chief administrative officer; and Charles P. Diamond, partner at OMelveny & Myers, LLP and AMDs lead outside counsel will discuss the details of the antitrust complaint against Intel at 9:15 AM PDT today on an audio conference call. Following their remarks, there will be a question and answer session.
Dial-in number: (651) 291-0618 Code: 786995 Replay number: (800) 475-6701 in North America (320) 365-3844 outside the U.S. Code: 786995 The audio conference will be available live and for 10 days after the conference call at www.amd.com/breakfreewebcast. AMDs Position on Fair and Open Competition AMD stands for fair and open competition and the value and variety competition delivers to the marketplace. Innovative AMD technology allows users to break free to reach new levels of performance, productivity and creativity. Businesses and consumers should have the freedom to choose from a range of competitive products that come from continuous innovation. When market forces work, consumers have choice and everyone wins. For more information, please visit http://www.amd.com/breakfree.
About AMD AMD (NYSE:AMD) designs and produces innovative microprocessors, Flash memory devices and low-power processor solutions for the computer, communications and consumer electronics industries. AMD is dedicated to delivering standards-based, customer-focused solutions for technology users, ranging from enterprises to government agencies and individual consumers. For more information, visit www.amd.com.
AMD, the AMD Arrow logo and combinations thereof, are trademarks of Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. Other names are for informational purposes only and may be trademarks of their respective owners. |
|
|
td> |
To: rdb3; chance33_98; Calvinist_Dark_Lord; Bush2000; PenguinWry; GodGunsandGuts; CyberCowboy777; ...
5
posted on
06/28/2005 8:16:16 AM PDT
by
ShadowAce
(Linux -- The Ultimate Windows Service Pack)
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
Meanwhile Intel announces :
Intel Completes 64-Bit Transition With Introduction Of Intel® Celeron® D Processor For Value PCs
*************************************************************
Intel Completes 64-Bit Transition With Celeron D:
With the introduction today of the Intel® Celeron® D processor 351, Intel Corporation now has Intel® Extended Memory 64 Technology (Intel EM64T), or 64-bit memory addressability, available throughout its entire desktop and server processor lines. With appropriate 64-bit supporting hardware and software, PCs based on an Intel processor supporting Intel EM64T can enable the use of extended virtual and physical memory. For example, on digital media applications 64-bit desktop computing enables faster performance with its ability to process more in main memory, also referred to as RAM, due to less data caching to and from the hard drive. Also, Intel processors supporting Intel EM64T provide headroom for processing high-definition video by enabling improvements in both speed and quality of workflow with its ability to handle large amounts of data.
To: ShadowAce
See #6, what's up with all of this?
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
It sounds like Intel is extending its line-up of 64-bits chips to the Celeron. At least what it
calls 64-bit chips. I'm not at all sold on Intel's implementation of 64-bit addressability yet.
I think the main purpose of this is to snare the low-end user before AMD does. It's a VHS-vs-Betamax mentality, I believe. They're oing after the mass market as fast as they can in order to win the market before AMD does.
8
posted on
06/28/2005 8:24:48 AM PDT
by
ShadowAce
(Linux -- The Ultimate Windows Service Pack)
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
I haven't built an Intel machine in YEARS. ALL have been AMD over 40 of them, for friends and family.
9
posted on
06/28/2005 10:37:13 AM PDT
by
Echo Talon
(http://echotalon.blogspot.com)
To: ShadowAce
10
posted on
06/28/2005 10:39:38 AM PDT
by
Echo Talon
(http://echotalon.blogspot.com)
To: Echo Talon
Yeah--that's to be expected. I fully expect nothing but 64-bit machines to be available within two years. I'm being conservative here, because I don't know what the average consumer will demand.
11
posted on
06/28/2005 10:45:10 AM PDT
by
ShadowAce
(Linux -- The Ultimate Windows Service Pack)
To: ShadowAce
word is Sempron is going 64bit in July... :D
12
posted on
06/28/2005 10:46:31 AM PDT
by
Echo Talon
(http://echotalon.blogspot.com)
To: ShadowAce
AMD Athlon 64 X2 4800+
Dual-Core 1MB Per Core 90nm 939pin -
Retail w/fan - Direct Connect Architecture - AMDs on-chip
integrated memory controller - Enables true multitasking -
Taking Preorders on a First-Come First-Serve Basis
Dealer # - 120243
Man # -ADA4800CDBOX
Read more at
Monarchcomputer
13
posted on
06/28/2005 10:53:25 AM PDT
by
Echo Talon
(http://echotalon.blogspot.com)
To: Echo Talon
LOL! What's a "Lederboard?"
Seriously, I believe that my next machine will be an AMD.
14
posted on
06/28/2005 10:56:16 AM PDT
by
ShadowAce
(Linux -- The Ultimate Windows Service Pack)
To: Echo Talon
word is Sempron is going 64bit in July... :DWhich socket?
To: ShadowAce
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
17
posted on
06/28/2005 11:00:14 AM PDT
by
Echo Talon
(http://echotalon.blogspot.com)
To: ShadowAce
LOL! What's a "Lederboard?" It must be the top of the benchmark list. That that magazine uses... Alex "Sharky" Ross, CPU Magazine, July 2005
18
posted on
06/28/2005 11:03:28 AM PDT
by
Echo Talon
(http://echotalon.blogspot.com)
To: ShadowAce
LOL! What's a "Lederboard?" DOH!!!! LOL!!! I thought you mispelled it! LOL! THEY DID! LOL! Sorry 'bout that! hehe
19
posted on
06/28/2005 11:05:05 AM PDT
by
Echo Talon
(http://echotalon.blogspot.com)
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
Ditto !!!!! Always have, always will !
20
posted on
06/28/2005 4:02:50 PM PDT
by
dfwddr
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-22 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson