Posted on 06/20/2005 8:36:34 PM PDT by Republicanprofessor
Ping.
Art Appreciation/Education ping list. Let me know if you want on or off this list.
Please add me to the list. Also is there a backlist of links, since I am adding the course late and need to catch up.
The previous posts are:
class 4: Expressionism
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-chat/1424087/posts
class 3: Cezanne and van Gogh
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-chat/1419876/posts
class 2: Impressionism and Post-Impressionism
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-chat/1414727/posts
class 1: Realism: Manet and Homer
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1410117/posts
Feel free to make continuing comments on the "old" classes, or bring the comments into the most current thread.
The next "class" will probably be later this week, on Surrealism. Next week: Abstract Expressionism (that's Pollock).
Nothing about these paintings makes me feel good (or perhaps I should say "feel appreciative"). The sensory overload is too much for my tastes. I understand Piccaso and Cubism a little better, thanks to your lesson, but I don't like the style today any more than I did yesterday.
Comparable musicians at the time include Igor Stravinsky. His Rite of Spring from 1912-13, is emtional and much like Matisse and his Dance. But his later works are also cerebral and sometimes can be seen as patchworks, much like the planes of Cubism. His work after Rite is much less emotional and I can't get into it beyond an intellectual exercise.
In case any one wants to get into the music of the time too:
for Rite:
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B000000C0U/qid=1119353850/sr=1-2/ref=sr_1_2/104-1607871-9664746?v=glance&s=classical
For Soldier's Story: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00005M9HW/qid=1119353935/sr=8-13/ref=pd_ka_6/104-1607871-9664746?v=glance&s=music&n=507846
I've done this art thread, but since I added something about "classical" music of the time (i.e. Stravinsky), I thought I'd expand the pings to music in case you guys want to chime in.
Bump for later appreciation!
Please add me to the list, prof.
Somewhat teasing of course. All of these would fail the sofa test resoundingly.
I've never understood what people see in picasso. The guy had to be stoned to paint so poorly. The pictures aren't even interesting. (You want perspective, see Escher (Hope I got his name right))
Firebird is remarkable too. Maybe that marks Stravinsky's homage to Rimsky-Korsakoff and the looming end of the Czarist Russia. Thanks for this wonderful series.
Thanks for another interesting class Republican Professor. While cubism is not one of my fav's I'd like to thank you for posting Picasso's Three Musicians. It's quite amazing. As far as the classical music series I would like to learn about more than Vivaldi's 4 Seasons :o) I played violin for 4 years in public school but switched to drums so I could make money on the weekends in my younger rock and roll days. Thanks again.
You are absolutely right. I forgot that angle (pun intended) as it is the usual way that Cubism is taught. The piece I like that shows this is a portrait of Picasso's dealer, Ambroise Vollard. Note how the bald head is emphasized. It shows intelligence, for Vollard could sell these early Picassos. Nowadays, with all the anti-balding products on the market nowadays, one might wonder that Vollard was not more self-conscious of his baldness.
Picasso Ambroise Vollard 1911
Note also that Vollard is a big man (I think), and yet his lower body dissolves into the background. Otherwise, this has all the smaller, modeled planes and dull color of early Analytical Cubism.
I have to listen to Firebird more. I get into Stravinsky when I teach an interdisciplinary humanities course, and then I don't listen to him for a while.
Chimps and 4 year olds may make pretty decorations, but for me they are not profound art nor are they worth $32,000. But gullible fools can be found everywhere. And we all have different tastes, and I may be proven wrong.
Interesting point. I'll have to listen again to more later pieces. He definitely plays with broken, changing rhythms and the repetition of small parts of melodies (aka ostinati) in all his works. But they just don't have that raw, emotional impact from the Rite that I love so much.
The Teaching Company has comprehensive sales every few months, and this series of 48 CDs, I think, is about $100 on sale and definitely worth it. Greenberg has a great senes of humor and will get you to HEAR. He's wonderful. (And so are the many other products of this company.)
This is where we start to part company. Much of the celebrated Modern art, while allegedly having something to "say", does an entirely inadequate job of saying it. The more abstracted paintings become, the more impossible it becomes for a viewer to extract any content beyond sheer emotionalism, and Congo's paintings contain that. I find Kandinsky devolving toward Mondrian's mere divisions of space, and Pollack as inarticulate as that chimp. At the current end of that trail, you have rotting cows in museum showcases.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.