carrie will win this one. They've failed twice trying to go Hip-Hop with the winners. They can't afford another non-selling "American Idol." Carrie will be marketed like Kelly Clarkson was/is (pop princess Diva), despite the fact that she is probably more suited to be someone like LeAnn rhimes.
I think you're right on. She's more marketable. I'm pulling for Bo though. I like his attitude.
You are none-too-bright!
Fantasia's project reached number 2 on the Billboard R&B Chart and presently resides at #11. The "HipHop" project, as you put it (when it is really R&B), peaked at number 8 on the Billboard 200 Chart and has occupied a position for 22 weeks.
Now tell me Brainiac, how has Fantasia's effort been a financial failure? Stop speaking nonsense! You are probably upset that Clay (that effeminate guy) lost to big boy.
P.S. I don't even care for Fantasia - but facts are facts!
Also, Clarkson's first project did not burn up the charts!