[A CA Guy]

Not at all, she's hot, loud and sings in tune.

I think she gets a career in musical theater.

[A CA Guy]

Ping

[Tx Angel]

She's pretty. Probably has a sweet personality.

But she can't hold a tune for shite.

[L.N. Smithee]

Not at all, [Vonzell]'s hot, loud and sings in tune. I think she gets a career in musical theater.

Maybe you can help me with this: so many of the auditioners were dismissed by Cowell as being suited for musical theater, suggesting that they weren't good enough to be pop stars. I don't know about you, but I don't think of people capable of musical theater as less talented than pop stars! Does Cowell think that Britney Spears or Ashlee Simpson would last a week on Broadway, knowing their vocal shortcomings can't be mixed away by a record producer when they are before a live audience?

I still think Nicole "Scooter Girl" Tieri would have contended last season.