I didn't realize your parents were converts. My Daddy didn't join the Church until about the time I was born. I think he was confirmed the year my oldest sister was. Mama was a cradle Catholic.
Yeah, my Dad didn't convert until I was five. The four oldest of us kids were baptized at the same time. I remember it.
Mom kinda sorta converted in high school, but I don't think completely understood the faith. She fell away for a lot of years, but came back when Dad joined.