The only thing I could figure was that Jonathan was the one that dove in the water with Steph (?) at the very beginning to get to the beach, and they both got beaten by the boat. Course, it was Caryn (the liberal loud mouthed lawyer) that chose Willard over Jonathan, so who knows what devious plans she had. ;) I also figure that Willard could be an easy target for a vote, being the oldest. IMO
She chose him for personal reasons, not for the team. I think she assumed she would easily form an alliance with Willard and be able to dominate him. She could do neither with Jonathan.
However, Willard may indeed outsmart her. A former marine, he's much tougher than he looks.
I dozed off during the end of Survivor last night. Did Caryn and/or Willard contribute to solving the Morse Code puzzle? Who was responsible for getting it right?