She chose him for personal reasons, not for the team. I think she assumed she would easily form an alliance with Willard and be able to dominate him. She could do neither with Jonathan.
However, Willard may indeed outsmart her. A former marine, he's much tougher than he looks.
I dozed off during the end of Survivor last night. Did Caryn and/or Willard contribute to solving the Morse Code puzzle? Who was responsible for getting it right?
It looked to me like Tom dominated the decoding of the message. He is a strong player and my favorite so far, I like Ian too. The strong diver (girl with the brown hair) on Oolong is good too, I guess after a few more episodes I'll start remembering peoples names!