Amazon.com Reviewer suggests burning "Prophet of Doom" author in a fireplace

Amazon.com ^ | November 21, 2004 | "Proud Muslim"

[Land_of_Lincoln_John]

1 star

Good use of this book, November 21, 2004
Reviewer: Proud Muslim "Proud Muslim" (Fairfax, Virginia USA) - See all my reviews

There is good use of this book, in our FIREPLACES trashed and burned and along with the author!!

Was this review helpful to you? (Report this)

[Land_of_Lincoln_John]

Thanks to Daniel Pipes.com for finding this "review."

More on "Prophet of Doom" by Craig Winn here.

[Mamzelle]

Amazon will reveal names and email addresses of reviewers if the right pressure is applied.

[Land_of_Lincoln_John]

Amazon will reveal names and email addresses of reviewers if the right pressure is applied.

Interesting....

[weenie]

There is good use of this book, in our FIREPLACES trashed and burned and along with the author!!

Okay, Adolf...I mean Abdul...you have again shown us how strong is the connection between Islam and the Nazi's.

Again, we see that Islam cannot withstand the light of democracy and free speech.

[Camel Joe]

If you check the link to "read all my revues" you will find that they only review only books on terrorism. I think the FBI should be following up on any leads they can gather from Amazon. I think that Amazon will be less than helpful though.

[APFel]

Wow... Now THAT is an organized hit on a book if I have ever saw one. They all shout LIES! LIES! LIES! and don't address the content in the least.

APf

[Dano50]

So I should fear getting stabbed and shot because of an opinion expressed on amazon!

That in itself speaks volumes about Islam and its adherents.

[Mamzelle]

If you have a selling product on Amazon, have some econ "pull"--you can get them (with a phone call) to post the identities of reviewers. There is no privacy in reviewing on Amazon.

[ml/nj]

Wow! This must really be a good book! It makes the Islamic Swine so mad that some of them are giving the book five stars. E.g.:

(...), November 7, 2004
Reviewer: craigh whine "craigy boy" (America) - See all my reviews urrrrmmm i just want to say, i dont know how to read!!! even so i found a spelling mistake in your book: page 13, line 2. my mum was reading it to me at night(september 11th) and she dont even speak english. so anybody who doesnt know how to read i suggest read this book!! by the way i went on the images on google and i saw your face, like how much money have you got i am soo sure you can afford PLASTIC SURGERY... oh and not only have you made islam a bigger nation but you have brought the muslims in islam together, next time you want to right something use some CLASS... USE YOUR HEAD MATE.. x x x x x

ML/NJ

[101st-Eagle]

If you check the link to "read all my revues" you will find that they only review only books on terrorism. I think the FBI should be following up on any leads they can gather from Amazon. I think that Amazon will be less than helpful though.

Just let them get smacked upside the head with the Patriot Act and a subpeona. I mean, I hope. The gloves have to be comletely off now or soon. I am getting tired of trying to placate the Left and the ACLU at every turn.

F 'em, it should be all out war done with Realpolitik tactics. And be ready to ram the stuff through the courts all the way up to the Supreme Court if necessary.

[hineybona]

what the hell was that all about ?

[weenie]

Sounds a lot like the democrat reviews of "Unfit for Command"

[Rosenkreutz]

As far as I can see Amazon have just pulled the review in question. Probably too many freepers hitting the 'report this review' button...

[Land_of_Lincoln_John]

An organized hit, for sure.

Wow, that review has been pulled. Already. Power of Free Republic?

Here's another one, a little less inflammatory, but still there. Posted on the same day. What a coincidence!

2 of 15 people found the following review helpful:

1 star: Author is Moron with No Knowledge, November 21, 2004 Reviewer: Sam "Sams" (Ny NY) - See all my reviews
This guy has no idea what the hell he wrote in his dumbass book, he needs to be spanked and taught a lesson

Was this review helpful to you? (Report this)

[Rosenkreutz]

snap

[USF]

You're gonna love this PING

[Proud Infidel]

This "Proud Muslim" review sounds like a spoof of my actual review of the Koran -

'There is a good use for this book, in our FIREPLACES trashed and burned and along with the author!'

- by Proud Infidel

[FrankRepublican]

Amazon went out of there way to post my name for bashing convicted inside trader George Soros and his criminal record in reviewing his Bush bashing garbage.

[FrankRepublican]

"Sounds a lot like the democrat reviews of "Unfit for Command""


John O'Neill was so wonderful when he was on with Kopell, and all the other DNC shills. They would just scream and yell at O'Neill because they could not attack him on the facts.

The best (or really worst) was Lawrence O'Donnell melting down and screaming at O'Neill and calling him a liar about 100 times. It was totally disgraceful but you had to laugh because the Swifties were sinking Kerry's ship.

An what about Chris Matthews attacking Michele Malkin over the Swifties. Matthews was so frustrated that the Swifties were sinking Kerry that he just decided to attack Malkin.

[weenie]

The best (or really worst) was Lawrence O'Donnell melting down and screaming at O'Neill and calling him a liar about 100 times.

I would really like to hear a balanced professional speak to what is going on in situations like this.

We know that debaters who are unprepared tend to regress into ad hominem attacks, etc. but what is going on when an entire party or, in the case of Islam, when an entire culture regresses into a state of spitting, foaming...I hate to say it but there is no other word for it...madness.