[SuziQ]

and of course, the moment when Gandalf is telling Pippin about death.

Oh yeah, I was major fahklempt at that point!

[Alkhin]

I just wish McKellan had made Gandalf so rough towards Pippin. AT worst, Gandalf saw Pippin as a wayward child who may or may not do the right thing.

then there was that business with the palantir...I remember when my friends and I first read it, our thoughts were that maybe Gandalf set Pippin up.

oh well