Posted on 11/16/2026 1:15:20 PM PST by DFG
Elk Grove Unified School District trustees are set to renew the district’s nondiscrimination policy Tuesday, November 17. The regulation that carries out that policy calls it harassment to refuse a student’s chosen name and pronouns. It also permits students as young as fourth grade to be suspended or expelled for harassment, including misgendering.
The policy itself, Board Policy 5145.18, never mentions pronouns. The pronoun rule sits in Administrative Regulation 5145.18, which district staff write and the board does not vote on. But the regulation exists to enforce the board’s policy, and trustees can direct staff to change it. In October 2024, the board approved the policy unanimously on its consent agenda.
One trustee has similar concerns. “I am concerned because Administrative Regulation 5145.18 restricts students’ First Amendment free speech rights and religious protections. I am speaking as an individual board member and not speaking on behalf of the Board or District,” Trustee Heidi Moore, who represents Trustee Area 7, said in a statement to the California Family Council. Moore joined the board in December 2024, after the last vote on the policy.
The timing matters. Since that vote, the U.S. Supreme Court, a federal judge, the California Department of Education, and even the California School Boards Association have backed away from the kind of pronoun mandate Elk Grove is poised to reaffirm.
First Amendment legal advocacy group Defending Education has already had success in its lawsuit against a similar policy at University of California campuses. In response to Elk Grove’s policy, Defending Education Vice President Sarah Parshall Perry provided the following statement: “The Supreme Court has held for at least three generations that one cannot be forced to convey a message with which one disagrees, whether on ideological or religious grounds. Preferred pronoun mandates are in blatant opposition to the protections of the First Amendment, and multiple federal courts have struck them down for just that reason. Suspension or expulsion of students who refuse to tow the ideological line on gender orthodoxy are draconian administrative measures that are completely odious to the Constitution.”
What the Regulation Says Under the heading “Issues Unique to Transgender and Gender-Nonconforming Students,” the regulation lists conduct that “may constitute gender-based harassment.” The first example reads: “Refusing to address a student by a name and the pronouns consistent with the student’s gender identity.”
The regulation then sets the penalty. “For students in grades 4-12, disciplinary action may include suspension and/or expulsion,” it states, “provided that, in imposing such discipline, the entire circumstances of the incident(s) shall be considered.”
Fourth graders are typically nine years old. Many students believe what biology teaches and what Scripture affirms: “Male and female he created them” (Genesis 1:27). Elk Grove’s regulation tells those children that acting on that belief can be treated as harassment.
The district’s policy and state law reserve suspension for harassment that is severe or pervasive. The regulation’s pronoun example carries no such qualifier, leaving students and parents to guess where the line falls.
Adults are covered too. “If a student so chooses, District personnel shall be required to address the student by a name and the pronouns consistent with the student’s gender identity,” the regulation states. Only “inadvertent slips or honest mistakes” are excused. Employees who violate the policy face discipline “up to and including dismissal.”
Courts Push Back Federal courts are increasingly rejecting compelled pronoun use. In 2025, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, whose rulings bind every California school district, held in Bates v. Wendt that requiring adoptive parents to affirm a child’s gender identity, including through pronouns, “quite clearly restrict[ed] and compel[led] speech based on both content and viewpoint.” That same year, the full Sixth Circuit ruled against an Ohio school district’s policy punishing students for misgendering classmates in Defending Education v. Olentangy.
In September, U.S. District Judge Fred Slaughter blocked the University of California from enforcing its misgendering rule against members of Defending Education. He found the rule likely “compels speech and is viewpoint-based,” adding, “There is no categorical ‘harassment exception’ to the First Amendment’s free-speech clause.“
The U.S. Supreme Court weighed in on March 2, 2026. In Mirabelli v. Bonta, it reinstated an order that, as CSBA summarized it, bars any policy that would “permit or require the use of a name or pronoun other than a student’s legal name or pronoun assigned at birth when the parent/guardian has objected to such use.” Elk Grove’s regulation contains no parental objection provision.
Not every court agrees. In November 2025, the California Supreme Court upheld a state law barring long-term care staff from “willfully and repeatedly” failing to use a resident’s preferred name or pronouns. But for public schools in California, the binding federal precedent points the other way.
Where the Rule Came From California’s Education Code lists gender identity and gender expression among the characteristics protected from discrimination. No statute says that using a student’s biological pronouns is harassment. That leap came from state guidance and model policies.
For more than a decade, the California Department of Education’s guidance on AB 1266 told schools to treat refusal of chosen names and pronouns as harassment. CDE has since replaced it with AB 1955 guidance that contains no pronoun mandate and no harassment example.
The model language spread through the California School Boards Association, a nonprofit representing nearly 1,000 school districts and county offices of education. Districts lean on its sample policies to interpret state law. Elk Grove posts its policies through CSBA’s GAMUT system, and its pronoun language closely mirrors the CSBA model.
CSBA keeps its sample regulation behind a paywall for subscribing districts, but its own legal staff spelled out the position publicly. In an October 2022 article, CSBA wrote that its sample Administrative Regulation 5145.3 was updated in 2021 and that its prohibited acts include “deliberately using incorrect language, such as improper pronouns, when referring to a student.” The article went further, claiming that “all staff, students or other individuals present on school facilities are legally required to use an individual’s requested pronouns.” (CSBA, October 2022)
Yet Elk Grove marks both documents “Unique Policy,” meaning they are “not connected to an existing CSBA sample policy or included in regular quarterly updates from CSBA.” That leaves Elk Grove behind. CSBA’s August 2026 update, written after Mirabelli, tells districts to accept a student’s asserted gender identity “unless the student’s parent/guardian objects.”
Elk Grove is not alone. A CFC review found at least 10 districts and one county office using the identical misgendering example, including San Francisco, Long Beach, Rocklin, Lodi, Exeter, Jurupa, Davis, Berkeley, and the Kern High School District. Los Angeles, and San Diego have their own versions targeting intentional or persistent misgendering. Chino Valley does not include it.
Pressure From Every Direction Schools are only one channel. Under AB 5, the Department of Education’s PRISM training requires teachers of grades 7 through 12 to complete annual LGBTQ cultural competency training. Under SB 923, health plan, insurer, and Medi-Cal staff must be trained in “using people’s correct names and pronouns, even when they are not reflected in records or legal documents,” and must retake the training if a complaint against them is upheld. Employers with five or more workers must provide harassment training overseen by the Civil Rights Department, whose regulations warn that an employer who fails to honor an employee’s requested name or pronoun “may be liable under the Act” (2 CCR 11034). The message is the same everywhere: conform, or face consequences.
The result is an atmosphere of fear, where people keep their heads down rather than exercise their rights.
“Christians teach their children to be kind to everyone, including classmates they disagree with,” said Greg Burt, vice president of the California Family Council. “What the school district is attempting to do is deceptive. It takes simple disagreement and calls it harassment, bullying, and discrimination. When a Christian child declines to use a pronoun that contradicts a classmate’s sex, it is not an act of hostility. It comes from their belief that God created us male and female, and that speaking truthfully is a way of loving others. Kids of all ages need their parents, teachers, and community leaders to support their right to express their religious beliefs without the fear of expulsion.”
What You Can Do Attend the Elk Grove Unified Board meeting at 6 p.m., Tuesday, November 17, at the Robert L. Trigg Education Center, 9510 Elk Grove Florin Road. Anyone can stand at the microphone and ask trustees to pull Board Policy 5145.18 from the consent agenda, and to direct staff to remove the misgendering example from the regulation, and add the parental objection protection now in force under Mirabelli v. Bonta. Parents in any district can put their objection in writing to their child’s school.
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
I am glad I moved away from that hellhole years ago.
I am glad I moved away from that hellhole years ago.
Satan has a throne in CA.
Ping!..............
They all have only one name - maggot.
That explains a lot.
Not surprising at all.
This rule is nothing less than giving aid and comfort to the domestic and foreign enemies of the United States.
In enacting this rule, the Elk Grove Unified School District trustees should be indicted, tried, convicted, and sentenced to a short drop and quick stop.
If we are going to compel speech then I’m sure I could come up with some new names and pronouns like ‘Jesus Christ is the way the truth and the life’ or ‘socialism is slavery’ or ‘Clinton killed Epstein’ or something similar.
Dammit. Where was this rule when I was in 4th grade? I would’ve violated it every day.
Failed communist state keeps diging.
leave the school. this will not stop until over 60 per cent of the children are gone from public schools.
Close the public schools.
bookmark
Years ago, there was a small group on Free Republic that repeatedly defended Calif, mentioning how FR was based in that state (as if that counterbalanced the liberalism)
They were always saying they were going to turn things around, etc.
Oddly, they have all vanished.
Nazi’s are gonna nazi!!
Why don’t a ton of parents go to school board meetings and cause all kinds of ruckus and call them Nazis just like the left does to the right I think turnabout is fair play!!
Use their tactics!!
They’re wicked.
This is what mental illness looks like.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.