Posted on 10/15/2025 9:52:45 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
The land I reside on, where I sit as I write these words, has a long history of human habitation, going back to the most recent major glaciation. Before Europeans came to Alaska, this general area, the Susitna Valley, was occupied by one subgroup or another of the Dena'ina linguistic grouping of the Athabascan people. The area started being settled by people of European descent in the late 19th century, when gold was discovered in the area (gold is a really powerful draw, it turns out).
At some point, the land on which I reside was taken up under the Homestead Act. The original homesteaded land was eventually broken up into smaller residential areas, including our 2 1/2 acre parcel. In the early '80s, someone bought this parcel and built a house, garage, and later other outbuildings. Then, decades later, they sold it to us. That's the story of this little parcel of land. Nobody stole it from anybody, and to suggest so shows nothing more than a profound ignorance.
Here's the thing: Every person alive on this planet today has ancestors who were displaced by force somewhere in their lineage. Every person alive on this planet today has ancestors who displaced other people by force somewhere in their lineage. It's an inevitable fact of human history.
American natives fought with each other over land and resources, and some tribes, like the Dakota (Sioux), were notorious for attacking their neighbors. Europe's history is rife with such, from the Vikings to the Norman invasion of Britain. In fact, few if any of the people of Europe today are the original inhabitants of the land they reside on now; the one exception may be the Basque of the Pyrenees Mountains, but even they, at some point, came there from somewhere else. The French people we know now derive their name from the Franks, a Germanic tribe, and as for the British Isles, that motley group of islands has seen so many invasions, from Picts to Celts to Romans, Saxons, Anglians, Jutes, and Normans, that it would be difficult to keep track as they go by.
Since this is an inevitable fact of human nature, why is the political left in the USA and Europe so obsessed with "land acknowledgments" and "stolen land" statements?
The left is big on virtue signaling, but this "stolen land" horse squeeze is one of the most egregious cases. Note that none of them - not one - ever proposes to surrender back their own property to the people they claim as the original owners. Note that many of them have quite a bit of "stolen" properties to give back - and yet they don't. Their claims, their "acknowledgments," are, as Shakespeare said, a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
This argument, this idea that some nebulous group of ancient people still has some claim to any of these properties, founders upon one rock in particular: All of the people who may have taken up these lands are dead now. The people who homesteaded lands in the American West are all gone. The people who took up and developed lands in the eastern United States are long gone.
Even if we admit any wrongdoing in how land was occupied and how the original inhabitants were displaced, we are none of us liable for the transgressions of our ancestors. It's the same problem with the left's obsession over slavery: All those people are dead now.
There is nobody alive today who was ever legally held in slavery in the United States. There is nobody alive today who has ever legally owned slaves in the United States. It's the same with these ancestral lands: All of the people that the left whines about, the people who may have displaced native peoples for their land, are all dead.
We can't return to that earlier time. And there is no reason why we should. Furthermore, the left's whining on this issue never makes the one acknowledgment that they should, by rights, make: That every person on the North American continent, regardless of ancestry, is better off now because of European settlement of the lands that are now the United States.
Here's the only fact that matters: This land I sit on, this land I live on, this little 2 1/2 acre parcel in the Alaska woods, is mine. I owe nobody anything for my ownership other than the property taxes I pay to the borough every year (and that's a complaint I will reserve for another time). I didn't steal this land. I displaced nobody. The people I bought the land from entered into a mutually-agreed-upon price and terms of transfer with us. They had not stolen the land and displaced nobody. The original homesteaders took up the land legally, under the existing laws of the United States.
This is our land. Our property. As an American, I am fortunate to live under a Constitution that guarantees my rights to my liberty and my property. This land is my property. I will not surrender it, and I do not acknowledge any other person's claim to it - and I will make no apology for anything. And anyone who would show up here and try to dispossess me had better come prepared for a scrap.
The land that is now America wasn’t “stolen” from anyone because nobody owned it. Native Americans lived on the land and survived on it’s abundance, often moving around seasonally or when there was drought or famine. They were more interested in hunting and foraging than setting down stakes. That someone one could actually “own” the land was a ridiculous idea to them.
Saul Alinsky’s 13 Rules for Radicals:
Rule #4: Make the enemy live up to their own book of rules.
Demand that the left return their stolen land.
Easier said than done. One would have to cleanse colleges of the hate america filth pushing this pollution
The left will never desist- they hate everything about america, and want us like europe where the elite rule beczuse they beleive they will be the rulers. They are power drunk, and need tk portray america as evil in need of “fixing”
The people who yell about this most are the ones who support unlimited illegal immigration.
Blah blah blah.
Red Cloud’s tribe had a treaty which guarantees them the land.
The US government violated that treaty
The entire planet is “stolen land”. Welcome to the human race. You would have to be laughably naive to think people found a nice plot of land and decided to settle there and the people on that land now are their direct descendants. uhhh no. Doubtless, people were slaughtered and replaced by invaders, people were driven off that land by invaders and had to flee for their lives, etc multiple times.
Stolen land has the same effect as Nazi, fascist and Hitler do but only for the left who are beyond utterly ignorant.
You forgot to mention Native Americans also waged war on one another, raped, pillaged and kept slaves.
There was never an ancient European skeleton found in Washington.
“Stolen land” is a liberal talking point. Say that to me and the conversation is over.
I agree with the article. That said, the Indian Removal Act (Trail of Tears) was shameful. However, as it was the work of Democrats, I am not ashamed.
So true...so very true...
Bfl
God Wills It!!!
RE: Red Cloud’s tribe had a treaty which guarantees them the land.
The US government violated that treaty
There should be recompense for the tribe if the treaty was violated by the USA. What is your proposal to implement it?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.