Posted on 08/07/2021 1:27:11 PM PDT by Jacquerie
The Roman historian Titus Livius (59BC – 17AD), better known as Livy, wrote, “History is full of fine things to take as models, and base things, rotten through and through, to avoid.”
The thread than connects the three Books and dozens of chapters in Niccolo’ Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy is his continual comparison of the ideal to the corrupt. By corrupt is not meant so much the embezzler of public funds, who, in well-designed republican Rome posed little threat to freedom, but more importantly the inevitable assaults and high crimes on free institutions which, over time, led to the republic’s demise.
Like Livy’s portrayal of early Rome, American patriots tend to view their founding era and early republic as one with many heroes and few knaves. Like Tacitus, I shake my head in disappointment of our governing form. At least for now, thanks to the election of Donald Trump, modern America needn’t fear a horror like that of latter 1st century Rome under the Emperor Domitian.
But President Trump is at best a respite from rampaging progressivism. Last November, just enough Americans in the right states saved the remains of our republic from certain globalism, open borders, and accelerating sharia. To survive post-Trump America, we would do well to consider the observations and lessons drawn by those who recognize the unchangeable nature of man and his relationship to government. Machiavelli is among my favorite authors. I find in his Discourses a go-to resource for an America that remains near the precipice of tyranny. The translation in my hands, by Julia Conaway Bondanella and Peter Bondanella, is an easy read and highly recommended.
Machiavelli found that one man standing alone is typically necessary to create a republic or lead the reform of an old and corrupted body politic. The quality that enables these rare men to undertake and accomplish their feats is masculine virtu’. Not to be confused with modern virtue, ancient virtu’ translates as ability, talent, strength, power, skill, and ingenuity. For their accomplishments to continue after their departure, citizens must step up and protect reformed institutions from ever-encroaching corruption. Machiavelli put it this way, “The salvation of a republic or a kingdom is not, therefore, merely to have a prince who governs prudently while he lives, but rather one who organizes the government in such a way that after his death it can be maintained.”
The virtu’ of ancient founders Romulus and Lycurgus is only matched by our modern republican founder, George Washington. Not only did he save the American Revolution, he stepped out of retirement twice, once to shepherd the draft Constitution through the federal convention, and again to set the example of a proper republican chief executive. Will Donald Trump assume the mantle of republican savior? Does he understand that lasting solutions are beyond the reach of elections?
As deep state operatives betray their oaths of office and continue, as they did under Obama, to undermine all that is good, I pray President Trump will conclude that even he isn’t big enough alone to take on and overcome Progressive corruption of a once free republic. I trust he will draw from his virtu’, call out his enormous following, the people who honored him with the presidency, and lead them to an Article V Convention of States. Per Livy, and after two thousand years, we know the fine things history offers to keep free government.
Article V ping!
To Rodney Dodsworth
How do I contact you? I would like to send you a paraphrased version of Machiavelli’s Tercets on Ambition for your consideration of posting.
Imagine Trump himself going state by state making the case for Article V! Offering to head up the Convention itself as a way to sooth the FOD fools out there.
Great imagery! I agree. PDJT could lead the end-run, the flanking movement around the Deep State, rats and rinos intent on snuffing out free government.
We know the rinos will roll over and pass the Obiden agenda. If this isn’t enough to prod patriots to real action via a COS . . . we’re doomed.
Machiavelli would have counseled a little more fox from Trump, whereas the Lion didn’t get him what he needed.
He was, as we have seen, outfoxed by the left too many ways.
I suspect a ‘24 comeback would see a more emphatic Machiavellian touch from a Trump second term. I get that he was up against so much, but he let too many variables up to chance.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.