Posted on 12/20/2017 5:39:31 AM PST by w1n1
Some debates between the .357 users against the .45 ACP lovers about its place in a SHTF scenario.
Most gun enthusiasts already understand the differences between the two calibers, such as the .45ACP power at close range, while the .357 performing better at longer distances.
But, is it good enough for SHTF?
Figuring out the logic of using one of these two calibers isn't easy. (this isn’t a scientific answer)
One factor will be your location and preferences.
For example someone that lives in Alaska will probably go with a .44 Magnum, but someone in Michigan would use a Ruger GP100 .357. Also, this caliber is better for longer range than a .45ACP.
.45 ACP users are mostly EDC personal defense carriers and those that love the big bores. For the availability of these rounds unfortunately, not as likely as a 9mm. Read the rest of the story and see the .357 vs 45acp SHTF video here. How about you all, which caliber would you use?
If I had to choose between the .357 and the .45 ACP, I’d choose the 9MM Parabellum.
Where’s a NOT AGAIN graphic?
I would think that availability would trump stopping power. I’d go with whichever looked more likely to be findable, because no matter how big your stockpile is, you’re going to run out eventually.
Which Caliber would you use for SHTF? .357 or 45ACP?
Whatever gun is closest at the time.
45 ACP, I HAVE 2 AND I RELOAD,A LOT.
Why would i shoot at long range with my pistol anyway?
That is what my Fal .308 is for.
357 SIG
Besides being great for defense, you can use the .357 as an effective hunting round, the .45 not so much.
For when the SHTF? The closest thing I can grab!
Own both. And we’ve stacked components deep.
One one hand the .357 gun has a lot of advantages. It can chamber two cartridges and either has plenty of power for defensive use.
On the other hand .45 ammo is plentiful and most, if not all, the pistols chambered for it have higher capacity.
I’d be perfectly comfortable with either.
L
.22LR
If you are stuck after SHTF with only a pistol, you are screwed.
I’ll be totin’ my Springfield Arms SOCOM16 M1A (7.62x51 NATO)with a bunch of hi capacity magazines. You won’t get close enough to use the .45ACP you are so proud of.
But if you do....I have a full size Springfield Arms XD in a holster on my hip (9mm, 16+1 capacity) and a nasty little Charter Arms Bulldog (.44 special) in my coat pocket.
I ain’t afraid of no ghosts.....
Both .357 and .45 are good rounds with stopping power.
I would use the gun I could most accurately hit my target, at varying distances.
I am quite good with the old army .45 longcolt cowboy gun, the Beretta 9mm and the S&W .38 special.
I am less good w/ the 1911 or the .357 mangle ‘em.
But I am certain that hitting the target is to be considered above all else.
I have a nice little .40 I really like.
However, My Griz gun... S&W.460 loaded with .454 Casull loads in 300 gr. hardened lead would take out 3-6 Zombies at a time. :) Just saying.
Perhaps a AR platform, 30 round magazine with Magpul trimmings and a 11 inch barrel is more of a utility all round choice in such operations.
OR all of the above. Yeah I think I like that choice...
In Nam, if u have to use the .45, it’s time to leave. You only have an 8 round mag and usually 2 extra mags.
I’m a .357 guy. Smith & Wesson 686.
357 Ruger pistol for me and my wife a 22 mag.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.