Singularly excellent.
I propose a variation on your #2:
>>The second theory of motivation is inherently cynical, therefore more suitable to her detractors, that contrary to the pattern of her previous life, she has devolved into just another pretty narcissist looking for the spotlight and not capable of thinking past such short term goals as tweaking the media and maximizing her financial status, even if it means leading literally millions of supporters into a false hope that she has the capacity for loftier aims.<<
I am not sure Gov. Palin has fallen deep into the trap of cynicism. I think she may have been ensnared by the “she Bear” syndrome which she has been both accused and honored for. The MSM went after her family. When it was just her, she would have been just cold and calculating. When they went after her husband, her daughter and then her granddaughter, I think something might have ticked over in Gov. Palin’s mind. Something that said “in the end you will pay.”
That may sound trivial and vain, but it also is too human.
To extend your analysis: why would Gov. Palin allow her supporters (and based on the attacks on me on this and other threads, I would not be too far afield to use the term “rabid”) to twist in the wind? Mos of the GOP candidates have declared, one way or the other.
My alternative answer is she doesn’t care about them and this is about her extracting her pound of flesh, supporters be damned.
I invert nothing — look at the plain text before all of us: Gov. Palin won’t run but she is enjoying her revenge on the MSM too much to let anyone — MSM, detractors, supporters — off the hook.
But your analysis is reasoned and I appreciate the thoughts you provide for consideration.
Your puppet line is both illogical and despicable.
I'm still waiting for your answers to my queries; don't let me down, I could use another good laugh.
Cheers!