Posted on 04/10/2006 6:45:04 PM PDT by B-Chan
Excellent point. The clerks dispensing welfare checks in San Diego once complained that they made less than the welfare loafers to whom they were distributing the checks. Where is the incentive to work if welfare pays more than you can earn performing honest labor? That is the root of the problem.
The whole "doing the jobs Americans won't do" is, as far as I am concerned, a slap in the face to honest Americans.
When I was a kid I threw bales of hay around, tons of the stuff, for a measly buck and a quarter an hour. I babysat, I pumped gas, I worked for a hardware store as a furnace installer apprentice. I worked for a moving company.
And as far as immigrants doing those jobs, what is really being said here? Can't immigrants be doctors? Or can't they work on Wall street doing financials?
Is it the role and permanent destiny of immigrants to scrub toilets?
People can come to America, but I don't like the idea of treating them as some kind of lower class. That's not the American way, but it sure sounds like what some are proposing.
Lovely.
susie
In your post 7, you asked:
"So just strictly on ECONOMICS, not who is right or who is wrong, where do we get the replacement workers to fill the Illegals jobs after they are deported?"
In my post 42, I suggested several possible answers to your question:
"Maybe we'll find that some of these jobs aren't needed. Maybe we'll find that the shortage of workers will create the incentive to find a better way to do some things. Maybe we'll find that increasing the number of legal immigrants is a good idea. Maybe the birth rate will increase because of the better opportunities available."
In post 77, you imply that I am advocating a position based on "data". I have done no such thing.
Your original post suggests that deportation of illegals will cause a problem. My response is that it might not. My response furthers the author's idea that supply and demand will operate and no catastrophe will occur.
We have looked the other way for a long while as the illegals came in. What did we do? Nothing, except rewards with amnesty.
Internally, our nation has been held up at gunpoint. We can continue the policy of keeping those hands up or else the government can return the United States back into a nation of laws.
Are we a nation of courage or apathy. Or are we beyond apathy and have become a dependant nation.
The great civilizations in the world have all passed through a series of stages from their birth to their death. Historians have listed these in ten stages:
The first stage moves from bondage to spiritual faith. The second from spiritual faith to great courage. The third stage moves from great courage to liberty. The fourth stage moves from liberty to abundance. The fifth stage moves from abundance to selfishness. The sixth stage moves from selfishness to complacency. The seventh stage moves from complacency to apathy. The eighth stage moves from apathy to moral decay. The ninth stage moves from moral decay to dependence. And the tenth and last stage moves from dependence to bondage.
/S
I agree with him. Unfortunately, not everyone understands economics. Further, many think of this question as a zero sum game, which it is not.
Illegals make the pie bigger, not smaller.
has anybody used this argument? If everything we eat - ie, fresh fruit and veggies, comes from caracos, uruaguay, manila, mexico (of course), and on and on -- and everything we buy mostly, comes from the remaining two thirds of the world ... why do we need people to pick our veggies or make us things?
Oh. Forgot, the corpo's use some (a handful comparatively, for construction work....
I am sure Maria was/is a nice lady. But she wasn't doing a job that Americans won't do. :)
And if it holds true in the case of modern agriculture (though in many cases, such as tree crops, it cannot) -- the jobs Americans won't do are going to become jobs that nobody gets. I believe I mentioned that above....
IOW, there's no point whining about jobs taken by illegals that will be automated once the illegals go away....
"Good arguments. It's a shame nobody's listening in D.C."
I've often wondered if any of the powers that be in D.C. monitor Free Republic. Anyone have a clue?
Actually, I think there are jobs where the pay/workload do not balance, so people will tend to avoid those jobs.
If you want me to dig a ditch with a shovel in clay muck for $5.25 an hour, I'm gonna look for work elsewhere if there is another job that pays the same with a lesser workload.
Digging ditches in clay muck is extremely hard work.
"Illegals make the pie bigger, not smaller."
Can you prove this? (In simple terms, if possible).
Even if the pie is bigger, are legal citizens better off?
Talk to my economics professor @ OSU. He'll tell you otherwise.
Illegals make the pie bigger, not smaller.
Very simplistic view.
We got rid of much of our manufacturing and still do so today. Ok, so our economy is distribution and consumer/service based - fine. Why then would we lower wages resulting in less consumer spending? Lower wages is the silver bullet to grow our economy?
Do you know why the 90s were so great. It was not because of taxes – Clinton raised taxes and the economy still grew. They were so great partly because there were high paying jobs that were created, money flowed through the economy, government revenues increased, the deficit decreased.
We have an 8 trillion dollar debt and a $350 billion payment on the debt’s interest every year. If our country is heading to lower wages, who will pay for it except the rich? All the government entitlements and huge military budget for the GWOT, who will pay for it? It won’t be those who work 50 hours a week and make $7.50 an hour and get their health insurance covered by the government (tax payer expense). We want hard working people making a decent earning with benefits, so they can fuel our economy, pay taxes, and don't have to depend on the government for entitlements.
More low-paid workers = bigger pie? The only people happy with that are the free traitors and socialist Dems.
Not only that, Latino Americans (legal and illegal) send tens of billions of dollars every year south of the border to help their family. Add that to your equation.
Funny thing here in southern CA, the illegal aliens who are doing these jobs are on welfare. That's why having anchor babies is so important to them. If you make such low wages, plus send money back to your home country, who takes care of you and your children? The American citizens do. I hear people say all of the time that illegals aren't on welfare. Well, their children are.
I read an article on the American Thinker website. The writer said that the follow-up question should be, " How many can we deport and how soon can we get started on that number?". His point was that open-border folks always say that you have to deport ALL of them at once or none at all. He stated that this is not a problem that happened overnight and it won't be solved overnight.
Of course, the work of tomatoes is largely automated now, so it's not particularly productive to worry about whether illegals or machines are doing the work -- in both cases Americans aren't doing it.
There are illegal aliens willing to do it for $5.25 an hour. Don't forget they'll want government entitlements. They'll send a part of their income back to their real home (a foreign country). ETC. ETC. ETC.
So long as they'll eventually vote Democrat after they have been given amnesty. And so long as the free traitors can make a small fortune by paying them so low... then all is right with the world. According to the elites.
BS! LBJ took the easy way out, and we are going to pay for his disastrous programs for generations to come. It set a terrible precedent. LBJ did more damage to this country than Clinton and Carter combined, and that's saying something.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.