I agree with you on the 2 different calls. It sounds like the call GoodLookingCellPhoneDude was speaking of was a message left on someone's answering machine, or voice mail. I am thinking answering machine because if the message had been left on a cell phone, wouldn't Beth have taken that phone with her for evidence? Of course she was incapable of thinking anything thru at that point. I am still amazed at how much info she was able to put together before 2 am June 1.From the clues she got from that call, she was able to track down a vehicle, and 4 suspect and their homes! She is amazing. I am aching for her tonight.
perhaps the "listen 3 times" bit refers to cellphone voicemail that wasn't deleted.