Replies

Omigosh...I am SO glad Im not the only one shaking her head in shock at those scenes...I could take Merry arguing with the Ents, and telling Pippin that they needed to go on...what I couldnt take was Pippin even questioning to begin with. It deviated quite a bit from the book characters. And it was shocking cause in my view, so many of the OTHER characters were right in line with how I perceived them ie Elrond, Galadriel, Gandalf, Frodo, et al. Why did Merry and Pippin have to be SO different??

I still go back to my worn out complaint that Jackson shoudl have, at least in the Extended version, had Merry and Pippin confront Frodo like they did at Crickhollow. Innocense does not mean stupid.

I digress...you are about teh only other person I know of that had that gut reaction to TTT...so many others have found it to be quite nice. And it was. But I am a bit mad at Jackson for trying to 'improve' on Tolkien's sense of humor. It must be a Kiwi thing, because the sense of humor I see them trying to do through Merry and Pippin doesnt match with the sharp wit of the book characters. He messed up Pippin's BEST line in FOTR! WHY!?!?

Okay...I'll stop ranting now...

but thank you...I was feeling very lonely about that LOL LOL!!!

I was feeling very lonely about that

YOu weren't alone! For sure. Now, where we may differ is that Elrond is totally messed up for me too. I could not reconcile Elrond in FOTR. But, FOTR was much closer in other ways so I thought it would be isolated.

The other thing was though that as a fan of Simarillion and all the other works too, I love Glorfindel. I wanted to at least see him a minute. I'm over that though.