[Wordsmith]

I'd say it's better than the funky live-action/animation hybrid that only did the first half the trilogy. Now THAT was a bad adaptation!

[Overtaxed]

I'm trying. to put both of them out of my conscious memory.

[Lucius Cornelius Sulla]

I'd say it's better than the funky live-action/animation hybrid that only did the first half the trilogy

Sort of like arguing the virtues of Wormtongue vs Shelob don't you think? I know, Shelob was a creature of power, whereas Wormtongue was only a corrupt human, but we are talking character here folks.