[Tuor]

I think that's part of the problem...some arguments about the movie, some about the book, and still some a combination of both.

As I've never seen the movie and doubt I ever will, you can assume I'm talking about the books. The very fact this sort of thing has to be established should explain a bit as to why I don't want to see the movie (a dead topic for me, BTW).

So, I won't jump on you over whatever you think about Elves in the movie, since those are Jackson Elves, not Tolkien Elves. :)

Tuor

[JenB]

Jackson Elves are really quite close to Tolkien Elves, except a little too blond and their ears are more pointed than Tolkien's Elves. Oh, and Jackson's Elves don't seem to have all those epics and lays and stuff. Otherwise they're the same.

[HairOfTheDog]

Yes, I am sure OT could serve up a great batch of Balrog wings! Or elf-wings if she could get them.

OT does not only bash movie elves. She bashes book elves too... and I see no difference between the two... as Jen already pointed out they are captured very well in the film that we shouldn't bother trying to talk you into seeing! But Took's corner would not be the same without her!