No, but I had a major argument with a geek friend... we were discussing military sci-fi... she said she liked a certain author, I liked another, and we discovered that she likes the 'big-boat' Navy style of military sf and I like the mobile-infantry or air force style. Fortunately I think our friendship will take it.
Gollum fan clubs simply do not enter the equation for me. Ever. I think I have a funeral to go to that day.