Posted on 03/14/2002 5:07:26 AM PST by HairOfTheDog
Sue and I did a bit of home improvement type work today, finally finishing up the fence repairs. The work went well, was able to reuse just about all the boards from the previous section replacement, ah, recycle and reuse, just sawdust left and the odd rotten piece. The wood pile needs culling though. The pleasant sound of hand saw, can't be beat on cool morning. However we're not total ludites, the cordless driver does make short work of long screws.
Gee, I can't even keep close to keeping up around here. It seems like only a few days ago we were celebrating matching the old Hobbit Hole thread, and now we're up over 6000 already!
Anyway, I found a place to live in Arizona, and have sent my resume off to one job so far. Only 3 weeks of tech support left!! (Unless of course, I end being able to find nothing else in AZ, LOL.)
Well LotR is now at the bargain theater here, so I am going out for a walk then off to the movie! Later.
Well, thanks, I guess. :-) It comes from having just finished reading The Book of Lost Tales. Seeing how the stories of the First Age changed over time from their earliest forms was *very* interesting. The Hobbit was written in the 30s; I suspect that some of Tolkien's concepts hadn't changed as much from their earliest forms of the teens and 20s as they did by the time LOTR was published in the 50s.
Rohirrim or Gondorians would probably see Beorn as something out of a child's tale
Well, The Hobbit *is* a child's tale. As I understand it, Tolkien made it up to tell his children at bedtime, and was eventually convinced to write it down in book form.
The one thing I do agree with about your comment is that the magic in Middle-Earth fades.
That's true, although in the earliest concept the Elves' "fading" meant something very different. And I find it very interesting that when the Hobbits are in Lothlorien, asking the Elves there about "magic", the Elves aren't quite sure what the Hobbits mean by the word. Even Galadriel, when she was showing her mirror to Sam and Frodo, says, "... this is what your folk would call magic, I believe; though I do not understand clearly what they mean ...."
It's things like that that cause me to wonder if Tolkien, over time, changed his own views on what was "magical" in Middle Earth, and therefore the early stories have things like shape-changing galore, while in the later stories "magic" is just a greater understanding of natural processes.
The original versions of the stories did have more of a fairy-tale feel, didn't they? Like Beren being captive in the castle with the giant cat? But you've also got things, like the Fall of Gondolin, that go perfectly with the tone of Silmarillion...
I would agree with that. As I was reading "The Fall of Gondolin" in the Lost Tales I kept thinking that I wished JRRT had been able to fully re-write the story for The Silmarillion. The story fragment of "Tuor and the Fall of Gondolin" as presented in Unfinished Tales makes me think it would have been something incredible to read in full, on a par with anything in LOTR.
Sneaking is a lonely business.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.