[HartleyMBaldwin]

FFS, Mina. Dune is science fiction. Fiction, as in made-up stuff. It doesn’t claim to be a documentary.

[Army Air Corps]

The author also forgets that the novel is set in the year 10,191. A helluva lot of innovation can happen by that time.

[struggle]

Yeah, why is some Japanese woman Neil Degrasse Tysoning at a film? Watch the Lynch one instead.

[Lazamataz]

FFS, Mina. Dune is science fiction. Fiction, as in made-up stuff. It doesn’t claim to be a documentary.

I second your comment. Furthermore, in many examples, she says it's not possible with present technology. To that I say.... DUH

[hinckley buzzard]

So many words, so much grunting and groaning for so little reason. The whole genre of science fiction rests on what we have always called
“the willful suspension of disbelief.”