The one between was perfect or nearly so.
The “one in between” (the successful two Starship booster catches) had a good launch, good release, good flyback to the launch tower.
But.
One (or more) instruments (radar transmitters? Laser sights? ) on the launch needed for final positioning into the two recovery arms was damaged during liftoff.
With no final “last few feet” guidance, they dumped the booster into the water right offshore at slow speed.