Posted on 12/23/2024 9:47:56 AM PST by DallasBiff
The word Christmas is not a pronoun, it is a noun, a singular, proper, abstract noun or an adjective. The possessive form is Christmas's. Example uses:
Noun: This Christmas we will be visiting my grandmother.
Adjective: We will bring her some Christmas gifts.
Possessive noun: Christmas's weather was mild this year.
(Excerpt) Read more at answers.com ...
I like looking for and finding the right word for a particular phrase or statement.
I may chop, crop, slice,dice, mix, mince or evenly blend different forms of words to construct my statements,
but I have never given any thought to
the word forms of Christmas.
That question can only be answered from the terms of context.
There are all sorts of opinions - and a style manual is exactly that, an opinion.
For Merriam Webster, the form changes under all sorts of circumstances (see ‘classical names’, to go back to our Jesus discussion):
https://www.merriam-webster.com/grammar/what-happens-to-names-when-we-make-them-plural-or-possessive
And when I asked my friendly household AI to show literary examples, it had this to say:
4. Proper nouns ending in s: In William Shakespeare’s “Henry VIII”, the character of Cardinal Wolsey is described as having “the Fothergills’ loyal support”.
These examples illustrate how possession is shown in nouns that end in s, whether singular, plural, compound, or proper. In each case, the possessive apostrophe is added to indicate ownership or relationship.
Further, the ‘Grammarbook.com’ tells us that there is no ‘right’ answer:
https://www.grammarbook.com/blog/apostrophes/apostrophes-with-words-ending-in-s/
As I said, I consider a lot of this to be opinion. I’ll stick with what I was taught back when even public education was still pretty decent; and what I’ve seen in a lifetime of reading accomplished English language writers.
It’s not superfluous. It’s only awkward if you accept that “they” is a singular pronoun and the “historical present tense” is not confusing.
The singular ‘they’ has been used for hundreds of years:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they
I figured you were one of them.
Oh. You also misspelled “misused.”
Everyone who speaks English as a native language has used the ‘singular they’ without thinking, many times. I don’t even recall it ever being an issue until the relatively recent kerfuffle over pronouns as they relate to sexual identity.
Natural language is a lot more than strict grammatical rules; a lot of it - and its efficacy - comes down to collective, accepted usage - which is constantly evolving.
(And now that you’ve shown yourself as not only very small but insulting as well, I’m finished. Have a nice holiday.)
I think I’ve always gone with ‘ignorami’; but both appear to be acceptable:
https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/ignoramuses-or-ignorami-ignoramus-plural
Language is darn complicated...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.