I had to search all the way back to April 26, 2023 to find where we discussed this, at great length, the last time -- here, and here and here:
Regarding the alleged Lincoln quote:
"I see in the near future a crisis approaching that unnerves me and causes me to tremble for the safety of my country.
As a result of the war, corporations have been enthroned and an era of corruption in high places will follow, and the money power of the country will endeavor to prolong its reign . . . until all wealth is aggregated in a few hands."
Herndon & Weik's books do not include alleged fake quote:
My previous posts focus on Lincoln's alcoholic lawyer William Herndon and his collaborator Jesse Weik in their 1888 biography of Lincoln.
Rick Crawford and Rich Buhler imply the alleged Lincoln quote originated from Emanuel Hertz's 1931 quote from William Herndon and Jesse Weik's 1888 biography of Lincoln.
However other sources, i.e., David Mikkelson, say that quote does not appear in Herndon's books, but instead was first seen in an 1888 political pamphlet.
So Mikkelson rejects Herndon & Weik as originating the quote, but instead focuses on an 1888 political pamphlet where the quote first appeared and was immediately denounced as a "bold, unflushing forgery" by Lincoln secretaries John Hay and John Nicolay, according to Mikkelson.
The only part of all this I can verify is that the alleged quote first appeared in Emanuel Hertz's 1931 book "Abraham Lincoln: A New Portrait"
Everything else is very murky and uncorroborated.
*YOU* may have discussed it. When I see you getting all long winded and wordy, I just skip the comment and go look for something else to read.
The only part of all this I can verify is that the alleged quote first appeared in Emanuel Hertz's 1931 book "Abraham Lincoln: A New Portrait" Everything else is very murky and uncorroborated.
As I said when I first mentioned it, you can find the quote in "Iron Heel" written by Jack London and published in 1908. So the quote is clearly older than 1931.
Also, Lincoln's secretaries are not proof he didn't say that. In *their* opinion he wouldn't say such a thing, but that's just an opinion, and people occasionally do things contrary to their usual behavior, such as RFK Junior dropping out and endorsing Trump.
I'm sure RFK's secretaries would say he would never endorse a Republican, yet here we are!