Posted on 07/12/2024 11:49:19 AM PDT by Morgana
The more conservatives digest what happened in Milwaukee on Monday, the more unsettled pro-lifers seem to be. Apart from the communist-like tactics the RNC used to ram the platform through the process, there’s deep dismay at the territory Republicans surrendered to Donald Trump — territory, some worry, Republicans won’t get back.
A few days removed from the shocking treatment of delegates, which they’ve characterized as everything from “demoralizing” to “dismissive” and “insulting,” more leaders are sounding the alarm that Republicans are betting their longtime principles on short-term gain. This document, former Congressman Keith Rothfus laments, is “an abandonment of GOP thought from Lincoln to Reagan — it abandons the true principles of our Declaration of Independence and Constitution. … [And] unless the delegates to the Republican National Convention object to this retreat, pro-life voters will be offered a choice that recalls William Butler Yeats’ prophetic words about a time when ‘the best lack all conviction, while the worst are full of passionate intensity.’”
Senator Josh Hawley (R-Mo.), whose conviction is a welcome contrast to his capitulating colleagues, spoke passionately about the need for conservatives to press through the cultural headwinds and stand their ground on these core values.
“Life is a principle that unites Republicans,” he insisted on Wednesday’s “Washington Watch.” “It’s one of the most important things that we have to offer the country in terms of our witness, and particularly for us as Christians.” And listen, he said, “We have been a pro-life party [since 1976]. … And I think at this moment in particular, when we see the right to life return to voters … we need all the more to say to [them], ‘You should support life. Here’s why we should be advocating for life.’ We shouldn’t be silent about it. We shouldn’t be reticent about it. We should be advocating for it. My concern is this platform seems to walk away from that and walk away from traditional marriage as well. And I think both are mistakes.”
As for this idea that abortion is just an issue for the states, the Missouri senator shook his head at the ridiculousness of the idea. “You know, this is an administration that wants to mail abortion pills into every state in the Union, regardless of what state laws are — regardless of what voters in the state have voted on.” So this president is already trying to override state laws. “Most abortions in America are chemical abortions,” Hawley emphasized, “and this administration is saying it doesn’t matter if you live in a state where either the voters directly or elected representatives have said we’re going to limit abortion or we’re not going to have abortion, except for certain exceptions. The Biden administration’s position is: ‘We don’t care. We’re going to send these abortion drugs into your state regardless. So it doesn’t matter what the voters say.’”
“If that is allowed to stand,” Hawley warned, “then the Dobbs decision doesn’t really matter much, because then the people don’t really have control of this issue. It’s federal bureaucrats who have control of the issue. They’re imposing their view on us, all 50 states.” If Republicans don’t intervene, then “my gosh,” the senator shook his head. “Nothing’s changed. People don’t have control of the issue. And I think as Republicans, we need to be clear on that. We need to be uncompromising advocates of life.”
Not to mention, he added, a majority of Americans agree with a role at the federal level — especially when it comes to the GOP’s historic positions “like no taxpayer funding for abortions, not using the military to fund or facilitate abortions — which this administration is doing, by the way — and not harvesting fetal tissue. ... As Republicans, we should say no to all those things, and we should say we advocate for life.”
The states absolutely have a role, Hawley agreed with FRC Action Chairman Tony Perkins. “I’m 100% for voters having control of this issue — I really am.” But Republicans have to be prepared to combat any White House that would trample those state laws. If anything, the GOP should be more engaged now than ever, he argued. “Just because the Dobbs decision has been issued … that doesn’t mean that now it’s time for Republicans to abandon their advocacy for life. That doesn’t mean it’s time to say, ‘Oh, you know, we’re indifferent on this issue. We don’t really care. There’s nothing to be done. If the military wants to facilitate abortions, I guess we’ll just roll over and accept that.’ No, no, no!” he said adamantly. “I think our advocacy has got to be as strong as ever, and we’ve got to redouble our efforts to build that national consensus, because now the voters do have the issue, and now we do get to decide it as we the people … which means we need more advocacy, not less.”
And yet, Perkins pointed out, there’s been this “almost stampede mentality” of Republicans running away from the issue. “And you can’t win a debate if you won’t enter into the discussion.” Frankly, he suggested, that’s why they’re losing. “They’re just not talking about it with the same passion and conviction that they had before [Dobbs].”
It’s exactly why we need to hold the line against these major, foundational party shifts. “This is what concerns me about the platform change,” Hawley admitted. “Listen, I’m not under any illusion that most voters read the platform, but it is important to the extent that it does reflect our principles as a party. And I think now more than ever, we need to stand on principle. If folks say, ‘Well, hey, this is now a matter for the people, a matter for voters, and that means we’re indifferent’ — we as Republicans, that is — ‘and we don’t really care and we don’t want to talk about it anymore. And whatever happens, happens.’”
“Boy, that’s not my perspective,” the young senator said emphatically. “I mean, my perspective is I haven’t changed my view. Every single life, every person is made in the image of God. Every single life matters. And we ought to be clear on that, especially now that the voters and their elected representatives have the say.”
I’m a staunch believer that life begins and would support the proposed Amendment (post 34).
That Amendment isn’t gonna happen. I know that. I also know that Trump and the RNC leaving it up to the States is not going to solve our National split on abortions either.
Abortion - like Slavery - cannot be determined State by State. We had a Civil War on Slavery and I believe abortion is the primary issue that might drive us into CWII.
You’re missing the significance of For being overturned.
You’re missing the bus, R2.
... Roe being overturned...
I had Hawley mixed up with someone else who I heard with my own ears but misattributed.
My bad.
Apologies.
In fact it seems I couldn't have been more wrong about Hawley, he seems like about the most conservative patriotic guy out there.
I’ve heard that excuse so many times, but the people who say it actually make it worse and worse. How can you win hearts and minds when you keep losing it?
Republicans ALWAYS fold, like a cheap suit!
Do you mean Roe?
No, I get the significance of that. And I also deeply acknowledge and appreciate Trump’s 3 SCOTUS appointments that made Dobbs possible.
But what I’m not happy with is Trump and the RNC ignoring the fact that this is still a national issue and therefore they are mistaken.
Abortion will remain an issue long into the future, but as things stand now, I think Republicans should support 100% the return of the issue to the states. And they should fight with every means at their disposal any attempt by the Dims to legislate abortion at the federal level.
Thanks for clearing that up. I was tempted to reply in my usual way - with tons of snark...
But that would not be nice. I’m glad you checked further.
losing what
It should never have been a national issue in the first place.
Wrongly-decided, corruptly-reasoned Roe artificially made it a national issue.
People need to fight this locally again, now that Roe is gone.
Thanks for the gentle correction. I’ll pay it forward =)
That's exactly what southern states said pre-1860. They were wrong and so are you. Abortion is the top issue for 1 out of every 8 Americans. And probably one of the top 3 issues for over half Americans.
This was, is and will always be a prominent national issue. Punting it down to the states is a cop out.
How come game marriage is a federal issue but abortion isn’t?
it can cut both ways.
Frankly, I'm surprised OH went as extreme as they did.
I thought most people wanted *some* restrictions.
“It’s far easier to work against abortion on the local level and then move on to help other states to support life than to try to eliminate abortion or regulate it on a national level.”
We have myopic people on FR who absolutely reject voting on the local level as a means of political change. All they care about is voting for congress and the president. These people are the reason why hard core leftists run school boards in conservative districts.
Agreed, it was a knee jerk reaction.
I agree with you on that.
You’re referring to DOMA, right?
It’s quite naturally already in the states, right now. No punting took place.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.