Posted on 09/22/2020 3:32:45 PM PDT by BruceDeitrickPrice
Cursive has been controversial for years. The striking thing is that the Education Establishment feels really, really strongly about cursive. They hate it! But why are they so emotional?
One professor of education stated emphatically: "Teaching cursive handwriting is an outdated waste of time."
A second professor of education, quoted in the New York Times, was equally dogmatic: "Districts and states should not mandate the teaching of cursive. Cursive should be allowed to die."
You are hearing the imperious voice of an impatient Education Establishment. They do not want to discuss pros and cons. They want to have a funeral and bury this nuisance from the past. Cursive is no darn good, now do what they say.
On the other side of the divide, many phonics experts think that cursive is essential. Most importantly, it makes children focus on the shapes of the letters. Literacy happens faster and more permanently when phonics is complemented by cursive.
When you have neither phonics nor cursive (and this is the official recommendation of our Education Establishment) you have almost no literacy at all. Isn't that an intriguing convergence?
Apparently our professors of education want exactly this sad outcome. They got rid of phonics starting in 1931. Just as astonishing, they have waged an endless war against it ever since, even though their own ideas produced dismal results. US literacy rates are low; millions of functional illiterates have been created. Isn't it reasonable to guess that illiteracy, at the end of the day, is a strategic goal of our Progressive professors?
Imagine their indignation when non-credentialed amateurs try to use cursive to pull phonics back from the grave. They have told us for 80 years that phonics is bad for kids, cursive is a waste of time, and that should be the end of the discussion.
Imagine the gloomy frustration they feel when peasants insist on disobeying. Arguably, the whole point of eliminating phonics and cursive is to make the peasants less literate and easier to control.
Reading is the most important skill but our Education Establishment succeeded in crippling it with a single stroke. They get a lot of bad press from killing phonics; but that's a price they don't seem to mind paying. There is now a counter-attack on behalf of phonics; many people say the balance of evidence is all for phonics. But our Education Establishment shouts, back off. They want cooperative, interdependent children. Too much literacy gets in the way of their social engineering schemes.
So that's the battlefield any time the cursive debate is introduced. Cursive is like waving a red flag at a bull. All the official experts rush out to denounce cursive in dramatic terms. Maybe it's my imagination but I think I can feel their desperation.
They must have figured out that once children learn cursive, they will inevitably figure out phonics for themselves. They become accustomed to seeing letters and syllables; they think it's normal to read left to right.
Our professors of education don't want to lose control of reading instruction, which means they must keep denouncing cursive. But none of the reasons they mention have anything to do with why they hate cursive.
Cursive works, that's why they hate it. Phonics works, that's why they hate it. Any ordinary person may have difficulty even guessing why the Education Establishment kicked out phonics. You might assume they would want reading; truth is, they don't want reading. Assume that and then everything they do makes sense.
The proper way to teach English reading is with phonics, not sight-words, but they have kept sight-words in the schools for 80 years. When children don't learn to read in those early grades, you know they can't read vocabulary from Geography or History or Science. So what are they doing all day? Not much. But the Kings of Chutzpah will tell us, there is simply no time to teach cursive!
When people go into teaching, you can probably assume they love education. But the people at the top? You should probably assume they hate education. What they love is social engineering. Education for them is just one part of an ideological machinery that most of us don't know exists. Education, real education, gets in their way.
On the good side, their irritation tells you exactly the direction you should go if you want improvement in K-12.
Get rid of the goofy theories and methods that they love so much. In particular, eliminate any version of Sight-words, any version of Common Core, and any version of Constructivism All of these things have multiple names because the professors want to keep us confused. That is something they do really well.
––––––––––––––––
Bruce Deitrick Price explains education theories on his site Improve-Education.org. His newest book is "Saving K-12 – What happened to our public schools? How do we fix them?"
© Bruce Deitrick Price
Gel pens for me.
I think cursive is a useful skill to learn, just out of principle. Some things were a mistake to eliminate and I think eliminating cursive was one of those mistakes.
Asked about it, he replied, “I find that writing clearly is a mere act of will."
OTOH, it’s like the millennial anti-theft device (standard transmission) on a car.
Kids these days can’t read it so if you write in cursive, you might as well be doing a secret code right in front of them.
Because cursive develops the creative mind. The Chinese stopped traditional language.
It is brainwashing. It prepares children’s’ minds for brainwashing
There are multiple versions in plain text available, in books and throughout the internet
And you just KNOW that nobody would ever alter them in any way ever, would they?
Cursive adds another dimension to communication that typing just can’t. It shows personality and emotion, it makes communication more human. Just like electronic communication robs the recipient of gestures, facial expressions, differences in tone and cadence, thereby reducing the true intent of the communication, so does the elimination of slants, angles, curlicues, dots, etc. as are found in cursive writing. BAD IDEA to eliminate it!
One of my students asked me why cursive was important.
My answer was that the Founding Documents of our nation are in cursive, and if you can’t read them, then anyone can tell you anything, and you can’t go back to the source and read it for yourself.
I told her that her basic human rights were enshrined in cursive, so she had better learn how to read it so nobody could tell her otherwise.
OK...I’m a rabble-rouser.
I’m one of the left handed types that loves typing and word processing. The most writing I do is scribble a signature.
Ink would smudge. Couldn’t write on a chalkboard well.
My handwriting is mostly illegible.
I took the last typing class my high school offered in 89.
Word Processing was coming the next year.
I had a very good teacher.
You must have used the old K+E Leroy lettering guide (I’m an engineer and I’m dating myself), as well as H2 and HB drafting leads. Now everything is at least AutoCAD.
I can read cursive, but thanks to a hand injury - as in multiple fractures that had to be surgically reduced) I can no longer write cursive.
I agree!
Bump
Handwriting is a dying art. I was taught cursive in grade school - as an adult, my writing is as illegible as any doctor’s scribbles. Most of us do our writing on keyboards and phone screens. Handwriting is mostly irrelevant. I’m more concerned about a lot of other areas of current schooling.
Really? So math is arithmetic?
Fsstest way to put down thoughts, for original thinkers.
“If you can’t read cursive, you can’t read the Founding Father/historical documents. Today’s K-12 can’t even print correctly.”
EXACTLY!!!
This is what I believe with all my soul.
They have removed this education in Cursive (and true history, etc.) to INTENTIONALLY dumb down and mislead the population.
This year I was very lucky to get my 6 year old daughter into a Private Christian school on very short notice.
And her First Grade teacher is teaching Cursive writing to the students! This is great and my daughter loves her new school and loves to write in cursive. The teacher is great and always available by email or phone if necessary.
This will be the best $6,000 I have ever spent (even though it is hurting us financially).
Push the kids to learn in school and they will shine and excel.
My daughters old friends in this sham Distance Learning will be so far behind next year it will be criminal.
Bookmark
Where’s spell checker?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.