That was before Cryin' Ryan came in and tainted the brand.
The calculation was they would retain all of their existing "right" viewers in the process which has proven to be a big error. But when the competition is a terrible as CNN and MSNBC are, they still have the greatest market share and revenue (2X CNN) but the trend is maybe not what they's like to see:
It's hard to find viewership or revenue data for the past few years but this chart shows that while FNC has grown in viewers, so has CNN. That could be because an election year floats all boats. What I'd like to see is data that would show whether FNC's shift to the left has actually worked in gaining more net viewers, or if losses have offset whatever gains they may have had.
I've long called it "We Concoct, You Deride."
BTW did you know Sean Hannity used to work in construction?