According to what I read it said she voluntarily gave them up. So the government still didn't do anything. UGH!
Hillary giving up security clearance:
“Hillary, we’re taking away your clearance if you don’t give it up voluntarily.”
Ok.
Voluntarily gave up her security clearance might mean that she declined to request a renewal of her clearance. Perhaps a renewal application requires some information on the part of the applicant. There is so much about how the Deep State and the swamp operates that we ordinary citizens are just beginning to learn.