But Eli has the bragging rights.
Super Bowl Wins: Eli 2....Peyton 1
And more importantly.....
Wins against the Florida Gators: Eli 2 Peyton 0.
Eli Manning has the best bragging rights of all: beat Tom Brady & the Patriots two times in Super Bowls. Eli = MVP of those Super Bowls.
Peyton is still the best QB ever to play the game. Eli is in the best top 10. Pretty amazing for brothers. And if Archie had been drafted by another team besides the Saints, he would be right up there with them in the list.