You’re right. I should have known. I have a collection of about 2500 classic rock songs from the 60s and 70s.
I was thinking of this “Tell Me Why” by the Belmonts (without Dion)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxcuOrI-dJw
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me
Well I gave you everything I had
But you left me sitting on my own
Did you have to treat me oh so bad?
All I do is hang my head and moan
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me
And if something I have said or done
Tell my what and I’ll apologize
If you don’t I really can’t go on
Holding back these tears in my eyes
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me
Well I’m beggin’ on my bended knees
If you’ll only listen to my pleas
Is there anything I can do?
‘Cause I really can’t stand it
I’m so in love with you
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me
Tell my why you cried
And why you lied to me