I don’t think the Voice judges would have turned around for either of the first two. Second one better than the wild haired Superman Kardashian.
This is beautiful! No gimmicks. No spasm dancing. Just good singing. Really, really good.
Keith: Beautiful song. Good choice.
Jlo: Captivating. Magical quality to your voice.
Harry: I'm questioning the song choice. (In a roundabout way, Harry is saying the song might be too deep for Idol, but he liked it)
Another good natural singer. This one is more upbeat that Katherine's.
Harry: We've seen a lot of polish. Wonderful thing about you is that you're so green but that will wear off. (needs to commit more to the song)
Keith: Not a good song choice. I like you.
Jlo: You are a phenomenal singer. You have to start believing that.