This is beautiful! No gimmicks. No spasm dancing. Just good singing. Really, really good.
Keith: Beautiful song. Good choice.
Jlo: Captivating. Magical quality to your voice.
Harry: I'm questioning the song choice. (In a roundabout way, Harry is saying the song might be too deep for Idol, but he liked it)
Katherine could be the best one. Tentative but sweet. I’m not remembering what we’ve heard her do.