No, they are caricatures of real-world discussions.
How is belief in a God less humble than disbelief, anyway? The latter elevates a moving piece of dirt to the “highest” form of life in the perceived universe, after all.
Haha, and that's not a caricature? How does saying "I don't think God writes books" translate into "moving piece of dirt to the highest form of life in the perceived universe".
Let me put it this way.
There are thousands of holy books in the world. You believe that they are all frauds, except one.
I just believe they're all frauds. They're ALL written by man.
What's more likely? That a loving God inspired all of his people in only one book, and the rest are deceived? Or that it's all man made?
I know where I stand.