I’m inclined to agree...I mean ok, he was on Layla and I Shot the Sheriff, cool songs, but when I hear him play guitar, it just doesn’t grab me. I think he’s pretty much coasted on his legacy with Cream all this time.
Agree.
I’d rather listen to Stevie Ray play the blues.
Second, no, most of the modern guitarists you name cannot play things that Eric Clapton can play.
Third, buy this: http://www.amazon.com/Live-Madison-Square-Garden-Clapton/dp/B001V7YWTQ/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1365225217&sr=8-1&keywords=clapton+winwood and then come back and tell me how he's coasting ... This is one of the great live rock albums of all time and it is just a few years old. Clapton is brilliant and Winwood is amazing.