[Cronos]

null-- Sherman correctly said The author is claiming that Muslims, as a group, dream of reinacting the Sepoy Mutiny in the West. Absolutely zero proof is provided for this. -- he is correct. And he is not any kind of pollyanna when it comes to Islam

the Indian Mutiny was not specifically Islamic, but was limited to what is now Uttar Pradesh and Delhi areas of the gangetic basin.

the richest and most powerful Moslem ruler of India -- the Nizam of hyderabad paid no attention to them and he supported the British

[null and void]

Another straw man argument, unless you or Shermie can show me where the author said "all muslims", or even "muslims as a group".

He explicitly said "captured enemy combatants".

Will you argue that the militant, active combat, murderous thugs are somehow not actually part of ummah? Will you argue that of the hundreds of thousand of muslims already infiltrated into the US, not even a handful hate America unto death?

Do you seriously assert there is nothing for us to worry about, that there can't, simply can't be anyone muslim plotting the downfall of "The Great Satan"?

As to Sherman, in whom you find no flaw and in whom you are well pleased, I advise you to check, really check his history. Perhaps Pollyanna is an unacceptably harsh term. Would you prefer apologist, or voice of moderation?