American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[Chunga]

Yuck

LOL. You're always sick of the best female singer in the competition. Thanks for the laughs!

[Chunga]

Hollie is safe. I wish someone would bet me real money that she isn’t.

[Aurorales]

Actually, no I’m not “sick of the best female”.

I LOVE Hollie!

And you chimmi-chunga can bite me. I’m entitled to my opinion. (should I LOL now?)

[Chunga]

She just isn’t that good — and rather than show the judges she could keep the pace, she fell down tonight.

I don't understand. She was quite good tonight, and her second number received a standing ovation from the judges. She's in first place at DialIdol. She nailed her second performance and really deserves to stay based on it.

Phillips deserves to go home. He won't.

I think Phillips, Hollie and Joshua are probably safe. I think Elise is at the biggest risk of going home, and I think she'll be joined by Jessica and Skylar in the Bottom 3.

If anyone but Testone or Phillips goes home this week it will be a travesty. Again, Phillips will not go home...ergo, Testone deserves to go. My opinion. Thanks for not reading it, everyone!

[Chunga]

You are entitled to your opinion, but if you think Hollie is the best female singer in this competition, you're deaf as a post.

Sanchez and Skylar are miles beyond her. It's hard to imagine anyone being unable to hear it. She did a great job tonight, but she's consistently sharp and she's stiff as a board out there (a quality for which you gave Pia Toscano a fair amount of grief last year).

LOL if you want. Thanks for not reading this!

[Aurorales]

Fascism rears its ugly head here every week. (Disguised as a know-it-all self-absorbed music expert)

You could almost set your watch to it.

[Chunga]

Set your watch and be on time. Hey, I throw my opinions around this thread like everybody else. You're the one who engaged me three weeks ago when I posted that I thought the vote putting Jessica at risk was a travesty.

You like to throw the word "Fascist" around. Look it up so you can use it accurately.

And don't be ridiculed into silence! Thanks for not reading this!

[Clint N. Suhks]

Way to go Hollie!

[silent_jonny]

The judges have BLATANTLY shown that they have wanted her out for at least the past 3 weeks, which is precisely why I hope the lass stays!

Me too. And she's a better singer than the judges will admit. I'll take Hollie's singing over Jessica's moaning any day.

[silent_jonny]

BEST group number in my Fantasy American Idol game...is...Oh....let’s just say a bunch of us get together...and we have a “Jonny and the Vandellas” (Retrokitten and I will be playing the part of said Vandellas-—and no offense to you Jonny for asking you to be Martha Reeves ;-) But hey...top billing, is top billing!

ROFL!!

[retrokitten]

I missed this post the first time around. LMAO Trust me, no one wants to hear me sing- even back up to Jonny in a dress and beehive wig.

[Netizen]

Elise at the bottom.

http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp?week=6&sort=TD&type=score&season=11

[Netizen]

Skylar shouldn’t be that far down, but I think some of Skylar’s fans might have voted to help Hollie. Hope it doesn’t hurt Skylar. :/ Having said that if Skylar did go home, i doubt it would take long before someone wanted to sign her.

[Netizen]

Agree. I try to ignore and refrain from commenting to it. Not that that helps.

[Netizen]

Good morning Jonny :)

[Netizen]

I missed this post the first time around. LMAO Trust me, no one wants to hear me sing- even back up to Jonny in a dress and beehive wig.

Can't you just visualize it though? :)

[ken5050]

They told Seacrest that if he couldn’t do the show, they were bringing back Dunkleman..Ryan did the show..

[ken5050]

LOL!!!..spewing my coffee..Best pic of the season, by far

[ken5050]

You go girl!..I’ve got your back...

[ken5050]

"I try to ignore and refrain from commenting to IT."

LOL!!! Nicely done...wonder if "it" got it?