I wonder if James peaked too soon. He wasn’t my favorite, but I liked him over Haley. Having said that though, I think James had a few performances that were off.
I really think Haley made it through because the judges Randy and JLo were so nasty to her. The judges are not supposed to be biased, their job is to critique. She’s the only one they critiqued so meanly. What happened? Their favorite was sent packing, while the one they threw under the bus stayed.
The Italian girl going home weeks ago so soon was out of nowhere. Now Durban (who is better than the other three combined IMO) is voted off.
My wife and I were upset by that. No way!
Durban has rare talent, can deliver on stage and we would watch him in concert anytime.
Anyway, when Durban was kicked off that ended our season of Idol this year for us.
I don’t really care about the others.
Scotty is talented, but we don’t want to see him give more blow jobs to his microphones.
Lauren’s mother may have met a brother to give her the booty, but she just IMO isn’t that talented.
Haley with enough paint can dress up for any street corner or Indian casino, but not for us.
Farewell for this year Idol. I loved the addition of Tyler this year.
Up to last night it was a very good year.
I have a theory on Haley and the question of who votes for her. I agree with your assessment that the judges being so hard on her probably worked in her favor. Why? Because from what I know of that age group (I work with a lot of them), her behavior is typical. The age of viewers who are probably voting for her have the same entitled brat attitudes she does. The judges picked on her and not only made Haley mad but her voters too.