Casey James
His song choice is Huey Lewis & The News' "Power of Love" from the Back To The Future soundtrack. The arrangement is kind of wimpy. And it seems to go on for too long. But it's okay.
Randy: I love you playing guitar. I think you're the best musician guitar player we've ever had. (thinks it was a'ight)
Ellen: Not a fan of the song choice, but best vocal of the night (what?)
Kara: You're on a different level. You're ready to make an album. You're in the zone now--stay there.
Simon: I don't know what you're listening to, Kara. Old fashioned. That song was old fashioned 25 years ago. It was like listening to an 80s cover band. (audience boos) Maybe it's just me. I'm English.