Andrew Garcia
For weeks, the judges have been nagging him to do something different, like his cover of Paula's "Straight Up".
Andrew finally gets the hint and performs an acoustic version of Christina Aguilera's (sp?) "Genie In A Bottle". It's okay, but it's like he's doing it only because the judges told him to.
Randy: Good idea. Didn't quite work for me. Pitchy (audience booed) Felt like the song only had three notes. No range.
Ellen: Great song choice. Felt like what you needed to do. The genie came out of the bottle too late. But I still feel people will love that.
Kara: You peaked so early and you've been chasing it ever since. Fighting with the rythmn of the guitar. Disappointed. Just wasn't great and I wanted it to be.
Simon: Kind of with Kara on this. A little bit desperate, Andrew. (yes) Didn't feel comfortable. Still going backwards, I'm afraid.