[silent_jonny]

Cook's first album has been a disappointment.

I heard his single when he was on Saturday Night live a few months ago. It was just okay. I had no desire to listen to it again.

Still, I'm glad he won instead of the monchichi.

[SunnyUsa]

I bought his CD - it’s “ok”...I like his single and maybe 1 or 2 more on that CD could be as good - but I dunno it isn’t something I’m listening to much.

As for monchichi my young teen daughter loves him - and his CD is prob better than Cooks....

[Wolfstar]

Still, I'm glad he won instead of the monchichi.

Neither one of them has failed, so far, but neither has been a breakout hit maker either.