Carly Smithson
Weber urges Carly to pick a song from Jesus Christ Superstar.
Weber: You've got to choose a song that suits you, that you can inhabit. I think the Irish eyes have it.
Finally--an upbeat song! Carly looks and sounds great. One of the best tonight.
She gets a well-deserved standing-O! Even Paula is standing and applauding.
Randy: Bigger voices are doing great tonight. Definitely good.
Paula: So unexpected. Loved what you did in the chorus.
Simon: Other than it got a little bit shouty in the middle, it was actually one of my favorite performances of the night.